Ahmadi-Thread

Peace Numb

Only one question regarding my post? It must have been a suitable explanation. Your question is:

Is this the last proof? My answer is clearly "no" in fact this is the first post that I have given that has gone into any detail. And in fact it is my first proof that he was not a prophet. Mahdi on the other hand will not be a prophet anyway.

You have finally tripped up again in your responses and I was waiting for that. Let me show you how ... first time you tripped was when you denied that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad could write such things and we provided the references. This time ...

You have said, "when he broke the cross and killed the swine with his great knowledge"

If this is true then why did he not go on Hajj?

Because the answer Mirza Ghulam Ahmad gave (see this thread) was that first he had to break the cross and kill the swine before he would consider doing pilgrimage.

So you are left with a choice ... did he or did he not break the cross and kill the swine?

Hadith states that Masih will perform Hajj, will break the cross and will kill swine, but it clear Mirza Ghulam Ahmad has not performed Hajj and as a result he also has not killed swine nor broken the cross because if he had then he would have done Hajj also.

Unless of course you argue that he has performed METAPHORIC Hajj

Like Hareem01 has said .... The proof of false Mahdi is the one who claims to be the mahdi. True Mahdi will resist baiyah and only accept 'leadership' when forced to do so.