Re: Ahadeeth: Accept or Reject
[QUOTE]
1. For Answer#1, It isn't mess up. Although you may call it tightening up of acceptibility standard
[/QUOTE]
Well thats absurdest of criteria i have eve come across.
From a shiite point of view, i know that they would site any Hadith that favors their point of view, written by a Sunni, even if sunis have mentioned that Hadith is fabricated. They wud also site Ahadeeth that go against their own beleifs and doctrines just to prove a point.
The existing criteria of #not going against Quran #of examining the integrity/truthfulness of narrators #of evidence of direct connection between the narrators
are the best available, short of Allah himself telling us which one is correct and which not.