A question from a Bralvi person, how come Martys are alive and Prophets are not?

[Muslim_Met_Fan]

Re: A question from a Bralvi person, how come Martys are alive and Prophets are not?

@Problem _girl

fatguru > ur defination of shirk make my point strong thank u

brailvee hazrat said ..prophet muhammad salal Allaho alyhi waslam can respond like alive persons ** when u call him , he can come every where ..**

. what does mean ?

now this person associate prophet salal Allaho layhi waslam on the same level of Allah coz Only Allah who can listin always any one every where! who have no death

and this called *Shirk *

The argument most Barelvis make is he's is Noor. He is everywhere now because Allah (SWT) has given him that quality. In my opinion I don't know how to react to it but I certainly wouldn't call it shirk.

A misconception Deobandis have is that they think Allah (SWT) creating Prophet Muhammad (SAAS) with noor takes away some of the noor of Allah (SWT). This doesn't make any sense. When Allah (SWT) created us and gave us some attributes does this mean Allah (SWT) lost some of the attributes? No.

Allah (SWT) gave us all attributes. We have feelings just like Allah (SWT). That doesn't mean we are on the level as Allah (SWT). Just because Prophet Muhammad (SAAS) is made from noor doesn't put him up to par with Allah (SWT).

No Barelvi worships Muhammad (SAAS).