Re: A question from a Bralvi person, how come Martys are alive and Prophets are not?
[quote]
can you give reference of the particular hadith
[/quote]
Hareem > well InshAllah i will post soon ! waisai if u belong to Sunni deobandi sect then i can also provide u about Books refrence of fuqha karam
[quote]
i** think there are some hadiths those say that earth don't eat prophet's body....thier bodies remain safe. can someone please provide ref for it.....**
[/quote]
yeah i think this is hadees of bukharee ..i ill tell u first i want to conferm abut it
[quote]
Yes...please give references of those hadith that prove that prophets are alivein their graves.
And I believe that one of the fundamental differences that define the gap between barailvis and sunnis is this very belief that Huzoor SAW (pbuh) can respond to us and grace us with his presence.
Being sunni, I can say that to suggest that our beloved prophet (pbuh) is not dead is totally against Islamic teachings.
[/quote]
Mazna > i wll Inshallah .. but let me one thing very clear that i said Prohpets r alive in their graves and he is shurely dead from this world ..
[quote]
U** need to find out what shirk means b4 passing such judgement. Tawhid or Onness of Allah, associating anything or anybody with Allah on the same level is called shirk**. I hope that clears your misconceptions, if anything it is Bidaa that can be used to explain this concept. Now whether it is Bidaa or not, that is a separate issue.
[/quote]
fatguru >
ur defination of shirk make my point strong thank u
brailvee hazrat said ..prophet muhammad salal Allaho alyhi waslam can respond like alive persons **when u call him , he can come every where ..**
. what does mean ?
now this person associate prophet salal Allaho layhi waslam on the same level of Allah coz Only Allah who can listin always any one every where! And only Allah who never ever die
so its shuerlly shirk