alo.. i reject the saying too, as do most muslims evident by the fact that you still cannot cite an actual instance of mass scale urine drinking.
Also keep in mind we are talking about 1400 years ago in desert Arabia, not in a so called super power 
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Muslim_Queen: *
Well Hindus think cows are sacred creatures and all, but drinking their urine is kind of scary.I mean people can actually do that- just the thought gives me shivers. Reminds me of a story my mom told me once.In Pakistan, there used to be some old man in the neighbourhood, who the people thought was good luck or something.So when he went to the bathroom ,they used to pick up his waste with their hands, and think it would help them.
I just think the whole idea of having anything to do with waste is twisted. Doesnt matter what benefits it might have- there have to be negative aspects to it.For heavens sake its waste. Does drinking urine actually have anything to do with the religion itself?
[/QUOTE]
what is average survival rate of pakistanis and indians ?
by your logic we would have been extinct by now
On the contrary there is more than a billion of you 
^ you are not understanding the legislative process Ravage. THe whole state doesn;t make it mandatory to drink urine. Maybe this is where the khilafah went wring. They were probably under a camel.
i mean, come on. im surprised at Matsui.. he actually defended the practice!
hadh hoti hay.
anyhow. peace (yes, the resemblance is uncanny) out.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Matsui: *
^ you are not understanding the legislative process Ravage. THe whole state doesn;t make it mandatory to drink urine. Maybe this is where the khilafah went wring. They were probably under a camel.
[/QUOTE]
the article also states that inspite of the multiple products fielded, demand exceeded supply.
I defended the right for people to sell it ina democratic society should there be buyers for the good,as long as it doesn;t hurt the populace. Nothing wrong with that.
matsui dont insult the religion when you argue.
rvikz-- I notice you arent extinct.But do you not find this act of selling urine horrific.We're not comparing pakistanis to Indians.We're talking about Indians drinking urine.
Anwyay this whole thing is disgusting. Just the thought is scary, I cant even imgine that people would actually do it.
I guess due to the hot Bitech industry in India, they have probably taken out the harmful agents. It sucks such things weren;t around during the prophets time. 
MQ, you are suffering from selective blindness.
MQ do you find the idea that the prophet recommended people to drink camel urine disgusting?
i am amazed at the way you people think. muslims claim islam is the most misunderstood religion, yet the vast majority of you make no effort to respect other beliefs.
Matsui, queer, you are either not understanding what im saying, or are unwilling to read it.
Piss drinking is not a common Muslim practice. Just because it appears in a collection of ahadith does not mean much, because theres levels of authenticity to ahadith. If it were deemed to be authentic, you would see a lot more cultural tendencies towards urine drinking in Muslims. There isnt.
matsui and queer Im not saying anything against you two.Come on.You all should act more mature when discussing issues such as this.Im not picking on you, Im just saying you all (ravage and the rest included) should stop saying how Pakistan is better than India ,vice versa nonsense.
Truth be told I do find it disgusting.Queer Im not familiar with that hadith.However I still think that drinking cow urine is disgusting.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by queer: *
MQ do you find the idea that the prophet recommended people to drink camel urine disgusting?
i am amazed at the way you people think. muslims claim islam is the most misunderstood religion, yet the vast majority of you make no effort to respect other beliefs.
[/QUOTE]
Gee you'd think it would be easy to make people respect cow piss drinkers? Oh the humanity.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Muslim_Queen: *
matsui dont insult the religion when you argue.
rvikz-- I notice you arent extinct.But do you not find this act of selling urine horrific.We're not comparing pakistanis to Indians.We're talking about Indians drinking urine.
Anwyay this whole thing is disgusting. Just the thought is scary, I cant even imgine that people would actually do it.
[/QUOTE]
your understanding of indian are hilarious i enjoy reading it.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by queer: *
i am amazed at the way you people think. muslims claim islam is the most misunderstood religion, yet the vast majority of you make no effort to respect other beliefs.
[/QUOTE]
actually, this is the first time i've opened a thread this negative about any faith, and in direct reaction to a lot of the crap that gets posted on Islam in the name of 'discussion'. as you may have noticed, there was very little desirer in my initial posts and those later on to carry any sort of discussion on, apart from a pissing contest.
anyhow. enough then.
MQ,that is you. SOme people wouldn't care. I find it disgusting too but if ther is no harmful effect from it, people can do what they want. It is not like they are sleeping with their cousins and bringng retards into the world.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Matsui: *
MQ,that is you. SOme people wouldn't care. I find it disgusting too but if ther is no harmful effect from it, people can do what they want. It is not like they are sleeping with their cousins and bringng retards into the world.
[/QUOTE]
matsui cousins do not bring retards into the world.That can happen whether a Chinese marries and Indian or a pakistani marries a gora.Now thats a very pathetic remark coming from you. If you agree that they should be allowed to drink cow urine- fine.You really dont have to say that cousins bring retards into the world.Its like that story about (unfrotunately) India again.The boy marries a dog and what not.You're going to say that its alright, because theres no harm coming from it? I mean come on, we're humans.Drinking cow urine is so wrong .
rvikz-- Im not here for your entertainment.And you wouldnt have a clue of my understanding of Indians.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by skhan: *
Gee you'd think it would be easy to make people respect cow piss drinkers? Oh the humanity.
[/QUOTE]
here's an outstanding ambassador to islam displaying the kind of tolerance he'd expect muslims to be handed out by non muslims.
ever heard of shame?
people, people, lets not quibble.
different cultures have different practices. We have a tendency to be a little more violent than healthy people should be, you guys tend to make gods out of cows. culture shock and whatnot.
chalo shabash thread khali karo ab.