just 40 needed....
Sami dissappointed me the most. Today he looked very ordinary..He has potential but not consistent
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Aejaz: *
Faisal Bhai please thodi details
[/QUOTE]
This will be stuff to talk about .... thanx a lot Mr. Ghuari u Dba$$ ..... the bails were remeoved before Kumble's backfoot was in the air so it's clear that u can't give out the batsman **
[thumb=E]215637_50139123.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=E]315637_50139121.JPG[/thumb]
Inzy should tell Taufeeq & Imran that the rest of the team is heading home - they can warp things up themselves... :) inshaAllah
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Faisal: *
Kumble missed a Kaneria ball... Wicketkeeper takes the bails off and appeals for stump wicket. It was referred to the third umpire.
[/QUOTE]
Faisal, Kumble didnt miss the ball, he played it on the leg side. :D Though that not being the point, rest what you said is fine.
Well well,if not an innings defeat,at least we won the test inside 4 days. :k:
*Shoaib talking to Dean jones admitted that 'i m no where near to my best but i m learning against these great batsmen'. *
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Faisal: *
Kumble missed a Kaneria ball... Wicketkeeper takes the bails off and appeals for stump wicket. It was referred to the third umpire.
The replays showed the Kumble was shuffling.. and his back foot was half in the crease when the bail was taken off, but the feet got in the air after that before the other foot came back in. Since it was so close so the benefit of the doubt should have gone to the batsman... but the third umpire (Ghauri) pressed the red button. I thought the decision was distasteful.
[/QUOTE]
faisal bhia...i agree but his left foot was up from the end a lil bit but definately close to the line..:S may be thats what umpire had looked up?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Faisal: *
Kumble missed a Kaneria ball... Wicketkeeper takes the bails off and appeals for stump wicket. It was referred to the third umpire.
The replays showed the Kumble was shuffling.. and his back foot was half in the crease when the bail was taken off, but the feet got in the air after that before the other foot came back in. Since it was so close so the benefit of the doubt should have gone to the batsman... but the third umpire (Ghauri) pressed the red button. I thought the decision was distasteful.
[/QUOTE]
Oh I see,
Well I dont think it would have made a difference to the outcome of the game, as we had already lost the match yesterday, only consolation is we didnt lose by an Inning.
On the umpiring Issue, if the 3rd umpire can make a wrong descision with all the technology at his disposal, can we really blame the umpires on the ground.
how can someone be stumped after playing the ball????
wud that not be run-out????
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by proudpakistani007: *
faisal bhia...i agree but his left foot was up from the end a lil bit but definately close the line..:S may be thats what umpire had looked up?
[/QUOTE]
It may very well be... but the third umpire was looking at exactly what we are looking at. Granted none of us is trained as an international umpire... but in this case, there was enough doubt.. and the doubt should have gone to the batsman.
Anyway, whats done is done.
[QUOTE]
Originally posted by armughal: *
how can someone be stumped after **playing* the ball????
wud that not be run-out????
[/QUOTE]
I also think Kumble missed it. Saby bhai thinks he played it. Dunno.
Anyway, Imran starts with a four on the third man off the first Pathan ball
cricinfo says lunch is taken??? 
At lunch pakistan needs 35 runs to win 
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Zero_one: *
This will be stuff to talk about .... thanx a lot Mr. Ghuari u Dba$$ ..... the bails were remeoved before Kumble's backfoot was in the air so it's clear that u can't give out the batsman **
[thumb=E]215637_50139123.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=E]315637_50139121.JPG[/thumb]
[/QUOTE]
Thanks a ton
Zero_one
Nice Rhyme that
:D :D
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Faisal: *
I also think Kumble missed it. Saby bhai thinks he played it. Dunno.
[/QUOTE]
He definately played it. Ball went from face of his bat straight to the keeper and he took off. Abhi lunch mai wickets dikhaayain gay naa dekh lena :D
from cricinfo....
actually Lunch has not been taken, sorry for the wrong information, umpires have decided that we have time for one over before lunch
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by saby: *
He definately played it. Abhi lunch mai wickets dikhaayain gay naa dekh lena :D
[/QUOTE]
ghauri must be stupid, but not all the other umpires/scorers to give stumping on a played ball....
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by armughal: *
ghauri must be stupid, but not all the other umpires/scorers to give stumping on a played ball....
[/QUOTE]
Its not that. There is a catch here, i dont rememebr the exact rule but somethign to do with positioning of the keeper and batsman in this stump rule.