16 civilians killed by US soldier!!!

Re: 16 civilians killed by US soldier!!!

why do you say the “bad apple” line is worn out? the validation of the bad apple logic involves only a numerator and a denominator. i think it’s as valid as ever given the enormity of the soldier population in question, even if you multiply the deplorable incidents by 10 to account for those going unreported.

the aggregate number of soldiers who have been deployed in iraq and afghanistan over the last decade would be the population of a major US city. any given population will have a sizeable number of bullies, bigots, and criminals including murderers…and the war context will obviously amplify those inclinations. if the guy who killed 16 afghans hadn’t joined the military, he would’ve probably been one of those evening news stories about an employee somewhere in missouri showing up to work with a gun and mowing down a dozen people…or perhaps an angry bigot who kills a couple sardars after 9/11. nobody would dispute that such killers are bad apples.