100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

1945 Tokyo Firebombing Left Legacy of Terror, Pain
by Joseph Coleman

TOKYO – For decades, Teruo Kanoh never revealed the terror locked in his heart the night in 1945 when American bombs turned Tokyo into a raging fireball.

In his vivid, unsparing paintings, U.S. warplanes shower the sky with rivulets of fire, and thousands of corpses — many of them women and children — clot Tokyo’s main river. In one piece, flaming victims plummet in agony from a burning bridge.

The paintings are a gripping testament to the destruction as Japan prepares to mark the 60th anniversary this week of the March 9-10, 1945, air raid that killed an estimated 100,000 people in a single night of fire.
**
“Civilians are defenseless, and this is what it is like when they are killed,” said Kanoh, who was 14 at the time and lost both parents and two younger sisters. “I want young people who haven’t known war to think about this.”**

The Tokyo firebombing has long been overshadowed by the U.S. atomic attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki which preceded the Japanese surrender that ended World War II the following August. But the burning of the capital, which resulted in more immediate deaths than either of the nuclear bombings, stands as a horrifying landmark in the history of warfare on noncombatants.

More than 300 B-29 “Superfortress” bombers dropped nearly a half-million M-69 incendiary cylinders over Tokyo that night and early morning, destroying some 16 square miles of the city. The attack, coming a month after a similar raid on Dresden, Germany, brought the mass incineration of civilians to a new level in a conflict already characterized by unprecedented bloodshed.

The official death toll was some 83,000, but historians generally agree that victims unaccounted for bring the figure to around 100,000 — overwhelmingly civilians. It is widely considered to be the most devastating air raid in history.

While critics in Japan and elsewhere decry such attacks as war crimes, others say the Tokyo assault took place against a backdrop of the increasing brutality of total war fueled by the militarism of the Axis powers.

The Tokyo attack was aimed in part at demolishing Japanese morale and hastening a surrender. Planners also wanted to wipe out small factories and drive away their employees as a way of choking the economy.

The American decision to go after civilians emerged from the failure of precision bombings against traditional military targets, and accompanied significant advances in technology and bombing tactics. The B-29, for instance, gave the United States greater range and firepower, while innovations such as low-altitude nighttime attacks multiplied the potential for terror and destruction.

The M-69s, which released 100-foot streams of fire upon detonating, sent flames rampaging through densely packed wooden homes. Superheated air created a wind that sucked victims into the flames and fed the twisting infernos. Asphalt boiled in the 1,800-degree heat. With much of the fighting-age male population at the war front, women, children and the elderly struggled in vain to battle the flames or flee.

Survivors say Japan has been slow to come to terms with the bombing’s place in history, in part because of the reticence of survivors.

Like other survivors, Nihei, who escaped the fire with her family intact, said the bombing showed that war is never justifiable.

“Those images in my mind … can never be erased,” she said. “I can see myself there, the flames all around me. And I’m running for my life.”

One can only imagine the horror that was inflicted on these civillians by the terrorist US government and its terrorist armed forces in Japan, only the recent anniversery of this event bought this incident to my attention. How on earth can anyone justify killing civillians in this horrific way only sadistic beasts could have done this kind of thing

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

ak47 weak post, this has been covered, do you just cover you eyes and deny what anyone else posts? MadScientist can explain it to you for the 12th time I'm sure if you would like.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

:yawn: This wouldn’t come across as the pathetic, biased and neurotic post that it is if equal horror was shown over actions of sadistc beasts that weren’t American and hit a little closer to home.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

wow these right wingers got short fuse ready to defend US crimes in one second shows why there arrogance will one day smack right in there faces

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

Actually, while I’m pro-nuke, I’ve always been anti carpet bombing and anti-fire bombing.

The carpet bombing strategy, and the related fire bombing strategy, were devised with the intent of breaking a nation’s people’s will to fight by illustrating that the war would lead to their deaths in droves. It was pioneered by the Nazi party at Guernica in 1936, practiced against Britain in 1940m and mastered by the USAAF and RAF in 1943-1945.

The idea was that if the British, and later German and Japanese people realised how easily they could be killed at home during the war, they would cease supporting the war effort and demand peace. The reality, was in fact different - carpet and fire bombing made people prouder of their nation’s ability to soldier on, and turned people further against the bombing nation

However, what is undeniable is that the goal of carpet bombing is to kill civilians, and this is morally repugnant and utterly unacceptable.

Strategic nuclear strikes are aimed at wiping out all military and economic targets relating to the enemy’s war effort in a manner that minimises risk to the attacking party. It just so happens that the only means to accomplish this is through a single large explosion, which would kill any population resident in the target zone as collateral damage.

So don’t put words in my mouth.

Hiroshima, Nagasaki = legitimate targets, civilian deaths were not the primary objective. They were selected as targets because their military and economic facilities had never been attacked before and so were operating at full capacity.

The Blitz on London by the Axis , and the destruction of Dresden and other German cities, the firebombing of Japanese population centres by the Allies = illegitimate military objectives and atrocities. These attacks had the death of civilians as their primary goal.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

“Actually, while I’m pro-nuke, I’ve always been anti carpet bombing and anti-fire bombing”

hahahahahahahahhah Maddy tu bhi na..:hehe:

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

It helps to leave out that the Japanese were among the most brutal and ruthless fighters in the history of the world. Plenty of laughing about precision bombing, but the alternatives are much worse..

And face to face is so much better? :

NEW DATA PROVIDES CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE
NEARLY 370,000 CHINESE WERE MURDERED IN NANKING MASSACRE

The Rape of Nanking is an innovative and credible work on modern Chinese history, according to Princeton University history professor Ying-shih Yü, who adds, “It is a solid and original study that maintains all the important standards of modern historiography.”

The work draws its main narrative from credible research techniques, including archives in Germany and Japan, records of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, and the recollections of survivors of the Nanking massacre.

While the total number of people killed in Nanking and its vicinity during the Nanking Massacre has been the subject of controversy, the evidence presented in The Rape of Nanking should put an end to this debate.

For the second edition of the book, published on December 13, 1997 – the 60th anniversary of the Rape of Nanking – the authors carefully reviewed the records of Japanese military units, the puppet municipal government of Nanking established under Japanese occupation, and Chinese and international burial societies. These records conclusively demonstrate that no fewer than 369,366 bodies of Chinese men, women, and children were buried or otherwise “disposed of” by these agencies. The records leave open the possibility that there were in fact many more victims, but the authors eliminated from their tally any reports that might conceivably have been overlapping or unreliable.
http://www.tribo.org/nanking/background.html

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

^ You shold read..."The Rape of Nanking" if you haven't already. Unbelievable...the japanese were equally as horrific as the germans.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

you meant pro-life, anti carpet necking didn't you?

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

what did i say about the right wing nutters making excuse after excuse even after killing 100000 people by burning them alive they make what yet more excuses!

pathetic!

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

^ Your last Khilafah killed 1 million armenians. Ever put up a thread on that? :rolleyes:

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

I am sorry I am lost where did the 100000 people die? And why are we discussing Japanese bombing now. AK47 can you help me I am sort of lost.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

^ I don't think its a bad idea to review history once in a while.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

AgSm: While it is OK to review history, I want to know why he is bringing it up? is it, that he is thankful to US for re-building Japan to what it is now or, is he trying to portray US as a bad country for bombing Japan?
History also tells us that Japanese were ruthless killers and had no value for life. Same as Germans and unfortunately I hate to say this it breaks my heart but some of the muslims (wink wink Al-Qaeeda members) are also ruthless killers.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

aKKK47: If you're going to dredge up stuff from the history books to support how evil and depraved the US is, at least try to do it right. The fire-bombing of Dresden by the RAF and the US in February 1945 is probably more chilling than the bombing of Tokyo.

As you decry the US for being the only country to use nuclear weapons to end WWII, you should always consider that the alternative of continuing fire-bombing using conventional weapons as in Dresden and Tokyo would undeniably have killed more civilians in more horrendous ways than the explosion of two bombs.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

^ don't you realize the ak47's USA hate is just a front? you think he doesn't know of condi's visit?

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

novoice

you are correct the UK bombing of Dresden is just as sadistic if not worse than the US firebombing of Tokyo it just so happens it was the 60th anniversery few days ago of the tokyo mass killings by US warplanes.

I don't know who are more sadists the British or the Yanks history is a witness!

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

I just love the way you choose to limit the comparison list in your threads regarding how evil the US is. It’s like: Who is more sadistic…Mother Teresa or the Pope? As between the two, one must be more and one must be less sadistic than the other. Although on a scale of sadism, both may rate less than a speck.

Your comparisons and postings are always intellectually dishonest because you refuse to look at or allow to be considered the full spectrum of relevant conduct. Once you do so, you can compare the relative degrees of sadism between the US firebombing of Tokyo and Pakistans slaughter of civilians in East Pakistan or Hitler’s slaughter of 6 million jews, or Stalin’s extermination of 20 Million+ .

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

They are saints and would run after US crimes with binoculars day after day.

Partition of India took away 700000 lives. they are proud of this succesful partition.
Yes any answer not as per choice is off the topic.

Re: 100,000 civillians burned to death by US bombers in Japan

Myvoice have you looked in the mirror when you talk about honesty?

try reading what i typed before you make silly comments.