Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

After the disastrous war with India that ingloriously concluded in December 1971, Pakistan had to face its greatest crisis since Independence. The dismembered Pakistan was left only with the four Provinces of West Pakistan; Punjab, Sindh, N. W. F. P. and Baluchistan. East Pakistan was now independent. Pakistan had lost a whole province of 70 million, 56 percent of the total population, and over 54,501 sq. miles of territory. There were 93,000 prisoners of war in India and Bangladesh. Pakistan’s international credit was depleted.

The dismemberment of Pakistan was also accelerated by the role played by the two major political parties, Awami League and the Pakistan Peoples Party, in bringing about a situation that resulted in postponement of the National Assembly session, scheduled to be held at Dhaka on the March 3, 1971. The events occurring between March 1 and 25, 1971, when the Awami League had seized power from the Government, resulting in the military action of March 25, 1971, were deplorable. The Commission also touched upon the negotiations, which General Yahya Khan was pretending to hold during this period with Sheikh Mujib-ur-Rahman on the one hand, and political leaders from West Pakistan on the other. Although he never formally declared these negotiations to have failed, yet he secretly left Dhaka on the evening of March 25, 1971, leaving instructions behind for military action to be initiated as soon his plane landed at Karachi.

Military leadership had been discredited. Disillusionment, uncertainty and pessimism prevailed. People were no longer prepared to tolerate misgovernment. The public severely criticized and accused President Yahya and his Government for ineptness and inability that culminated with the 1971 national debacle.

Faced with these difficulties, President Yahya ceded power to Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, Chairman of the Pakistan Peoples Party that had won the majority votes in the 1970 elections in West Pakistan, Pakistan peoples Party get 81 seats VS Awami League 160 in NA. On the request of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, on December 6, 1971, Yahya Khan installed a civilian setup at the Centre and Nurul Amin, a prominent Bengali politician who was against Mujib-ur-Rahman, was made the Prime Minister. Z. A. Bhutto was made Deputy Prime Minister on the same day. Nurul Amin remained Prime Minister till December 20, 1971, the day when Bhutto took over as the civilian Chief Marshal Law Administrator.

Well what i wana discuss here that what u guys think who was the main charcter/facts to break up of East and West Pakistan.

The Awami League`s six point programe?

  1. The Constitution should provide for a Federation of Pakistan in the true sense on the basis of the Lahore Resolution and for a parliamentary form of government based on the supremacy of a directly elected legislature on the basis of universal adult franchise.

  2. The Federal Government shall deal with only two subjects; Defense and Foreign Affairs. All residuary subjects will be vested in the federating states.

  3. There should be either two separate, freely convertible currencies for the two Wings, or one currency with two separate reserve banks to prevent inter-Wing flight of capital.

  4. The power of taxation and revenue collection shall be vested in the federating units. The Federal Government will receive a share to meet its financial obligations.

  5. Economic disparities between the two Wings shall disappear through a series of economic, fiscal, and legal reforms.

  6. A militia or paramilitary force must be created in East Pakistan, which at present has no defense of it own.

After the elections of 1970, differences arose between the Government and Awami League on the transfer of power on the basis of this Six-Point Program.

There ensued a political deadlock with talks ending in failure and postponement of the first session of the National Assembly. The postponement of the National Assembly session triggered a chain of events that eventually led to the separation of East Pakistan.

The Army who failed to reach on a compromise and failed to break the political deadlock between two big winners?

The Slogan of Ham Idhar Tum Udhar?

The Elections in 1970 were a totaly wrong idea under the circumstances of that time East/West Pakistan political and gerophical situtation?

The political history of Pakistan from 1947 to 1970 witnessed no general elections. Thus, when Yahya’s Regime decided to hold the first general elections on the basis of adult franchise at national level, they were not only required to make a new mechanism but were also required to set up a permanent election machinery.

share your thoughts please.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Just a correction
Nur ul Amin and Bhutto were only nominated.
I remember those days
They were called nominated all the time.
No one of them took the oath of their office

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

EyesOnSky,

Can you provide link from you did copy and paste? I am sure these are not your words. Perhaps you were not even born during that era.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

It was mostly based on the propaganda used by intermediate pass group to hide its cruel ,foolish acts with that time majority of Pakistani population.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

alright…

some of the parts I took from a site http://www.storyofpakistan.com/articletext.asp?artid=A070

You can find out other links when u open the site, personally I didnt find anything which lead to mis guide or minus propaganda about any of those threes main elements which i wana try to discuss.

  1. The Army role
  2. PPP role
  3. Awami League role.

peace

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

In December 1971, within a week of replacing General Yahya as the President, Bhutto formed a commission headed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Justice Hamood-ur-Rahman. The Commission’s responsibility was to ascertain the facts of the 1971 debacle. The commission interviewed 213 persons including General Yahya, Z. A. Bhutto, Chief of Air Force, Chief of Navy, senior commanders, and various political leaders. It submitted its first report in July 1972.

Originally there were 12 copies of the Report. These were all destroyed; expect the one that was handed over to Z. A. Bhutto. Neither Bhutto, nor the Army which took over in 1977, made the Report public. Though the Report remained classified, its contents were presumably learned from various writings and memoirs of the military officers narrating their side of the story of what the Hamood-ur-Rahman Inquiry Commission had to say. The report recommended public trials of the concerned officers responsible for the 1971 debacle.

http://www.storyofpakistan.com/articletext.asp?artid=A094

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

The first task before the Election Commission was to enroll as voters all citizens of Pakistan who were at least 21-years old on October 1, 1969. The electoral rolls were put before the masses for corrections on January 16, 1970, and after necessary amendments, the final list was published on March 17. The total registered voters in the country were 56,941,500 out of which 31,211,220 were from the Eastern Wing, while 25,730,280 from the Western Wing. The Election Commission also marked the constituencies, in accordance with the seats allocated for the National and Provincial Assemblies under Legal Framework Order, 1970. One hundred and ninety nine Returning Officers were appointed for the National Assembly and 285 Returning Officers were appointed for the Provincial Assemblies.

Twenty four political parties participated in the elections.

They were allowed to begin their election campaigns from January 1, 1970. The public meetings of Awami League in Bengal and Pakistan Peoples Party in the Punjab and Sindh attracted huge crowds.

Awami League mobilized support on the basis of its Six-Points Program, which was the main attraction in the party’s manifesto. While Z. A. Bhutto’s personality, his socialistic ideas and his slogan of “Rotti, Kapra aur Makan”, meaning food, clothing and shelter, were the factors that contributed to the popularity of Pakistan Peoples Party. The rightist parties raised the religious slogans, while the leftists raised slogans based on regional and communistic ideas.

A total 1,957 candidates filed their nomination papers for 300 National Assembly seats. While after scrutiny and withdrawals, 1,579 contested the elections eventually. None of the political parties filed nominations of their candidates on all the seats.

Awami League nominated 170 candidates out of which 162 were for the constituencies in East Pakistan.

The party that filed second highest number of candidates was Jamaat-i-Islami. It filed 151 candidates.

There were only 120 candidates contesting the elections on the ticket of Pakistan Peoples Party, out of which 103 were from the constituencies in the Punjab and Sindh. Pakistan Peoples Party didn’t nominate a single candidate from East Pakistan.

Convention Muslim League nominated 124 candidates, Council Muslim League 119 and Qayyum Muslim League 133.

According to the results of the elections, Awami League emerged as the single largest party in the National Assembly by winning 160 seats. It was also able to win 288 out of 300 seats in the East Pakistan Assembly. However, the party failed to win even a single seat in the four Provincial Assemblies of West Pakistan.

Pakistan Peoples Party managed to win 81 out of 138 seats reserved for West Pakistan in the National Assembly. The party also performed well in the Provincial Assembly polls of the Punjab and Sindh Assemblies.

The election results showed that the rightist parties were completely routed. The biggest reason for this was the division of votes among several candidates on almost every seat. Qayyum Muslim League, Council Muslim League, Convention Muslim League, Jamiyat-i-Ulema-i-Islam, Jamiyat-i-Ulema-i-Pakistan and Jamaat-i-Islami as a whole could only secure 37 National Assembly seats.

National Awami Party and Jamiyat-i-Ulema-i-Islam emerged as the prominent parties in the N. W. F. P and Baluchistan Assemblies.

http://www.storyofpakistan.com/articletext.asp?artid=A140&Pg=2

well these are quite interesting facts for me to get more knowledge about that era so i just want to share it here for every one.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

EyEsOnSkY,

Thanks for your link.

Following is the only role of PPP in your article of 5 pages. Never in this article ever mention the name of ZAB as responsible for the breakup. However many in past and still in present will justify here that separation was inevitable because of demographic and geographic reasons.

[QUOTE]
*Trouble started right at the inception of Pakistan in 1947. Almost immediately, East Pakistan claimed that as their population (55 percent as compared to 45 percent in the West) was greater, they were in a majority. Democratically, the Federal Capital, therefore, should have been in Dhaka and not in Karachi. *

*In the general elections held in December 1970, the Awami League achieved an overwhelming victory. They captured 167 seats, the highest number in East Pakistan and overall. In the West, the Pakistan Peoples Party had won 85 seats. The way was now open to draw up a new Constitution. *

The Awami League, now overwhelmingly victors, stood firm on its Six Points plan and refused to compromise on that issue. The Peoples Party in the West maintained that the Six Points Program did not really permit a genuine federation. It was in fact a unique constitutional proposal that proposed a federation that had power only over defense and foreign policy.

Efforts were made to start a constitutional dialogue and narrow the differences between the two Wings, but all in vain. Mujib-ur-Rahman's adamant stand in support of his Six Points, and his proposal that East Pakistan should have a sovereign status independent of Pakistan, further aggravated the situation.
[/QUOTE]

These were exactly sentiments of West Pakistanis in 1970 and 1971, PPP being representative of West Pakistan, upheld the wishes of people who voted in favor of the party. Though personally I think it was great mistake by West Pakistanis which included estabilishment, media and public in general. Later events proved that West Pakistanis should have accepted the 6 points of Mujib and a new constitution could have written to satisfy Benaglis who were persecuted and discriminated since 1947.

[quote]
*Mujib-ur-Rahman launched a non-cooperation movement. The civil administration was totally paralyzed. All government and educational institutions were closed. People were asked not to pay any taxes. The transport system came to a standstill. Factories and shops were shut. All government activities between both the Wings ceased. The Awami League setup a parallel government. Gangs of local Awami League freedom fighters, known as Mukti Bahini, led violent demonstrations and howled racial and anti-West Pakistan slogans, inciting the people to more violence. *

Amidst these disturbances, Genaral Yahya decided to convene the National Assembly in March 1971. But Sheikh Mujib-ur-Rahman unexpectedly put forward other demands such as the immediate lifting of Martial Law and power transfer to the elected representatives of the people, prior to the National Assembly session.

Unfortunately, on March 23, the Republic Day of Pakistan, the Awami League declared "Resistance Day" and Bangladesh flags flew all over the Province. There was a great massacre. East Pakistan had reached a point of no return. To quash the armed rebellion of Awami League militants, the Pakistan Army struck its first blow on March 27, 1971. Yahya Khan chose to use force to bring law and order in the country.
[/quote]

The demand of Shaikh Mujib was genuine about lifiting of Matial Law and power transfer to elected representatives of the people, Yahya Khan should have accepted his demand instead of choosing force in former East Pakistan, which ultimately led to separtion.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Though personally I think it was great mistake by West Pakistanis which included estabilishment, media and public in general. Later events proved that West Pakistanis should have accepted the 6 points of Mujib and a new constitution could have written to satisfy Benaglis who were persecuted and discriminated since 1947.

....................................................................

What u meant by West Pakistanis? is it mean west Pakistan`s Politicians?

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

The demand of Shaikh Mujib was genuine about lifiting of Matial Law and power transfer to elected representatives of the people, Yahya Khan should have accepted his demand instead of choosing force in former East Pakistan, which ultimately led to separtion.

............................................................................................

You better also incldue the name of Bhutto here too becuase he was also tottaly against Awami Leages 6 points programe.

or in your opinion Bhutto was tottaly inocent from all that happened in that time?

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Please read my reply again. Uprising of Bengalis did not start in 1971, they were fighting for their rights sicne 1947, even they agitated against Qauid-e-Azam for declaring Urdu as national languge. If Bhutto upheld the wishes of West Pakistanis regarding 6-point program of Mujib, he was also responsible. It was cumulative action of West Pakistanis rather than singling out any entity. All politicians of West Pakistan were equally responsible. However ultimate responsibilty always lie with the leader who has decision making power. In this case the then president who was also military chief, made two wrong decisions and whole country sufferred.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Although i agree with all the other points about discrimination by west Pakistanis, i think Bengalis were very arrogant about NOT accepting Urdu as national language.
It's true that they love their language but Urdu didn't belong to West Pakistanis or any specific province so Urdu wasn't being imposed on them. Urdu was chosen as the national language because it united all the muslims even before independence. In India's it's STILL considered main language of muslims so Bengalis should have accepted Urdu as national language.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Thanks, I dont have much time today to go further in this discuss becoz of my work, i will come back soon for further discuss when i have a free time.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

Thanks to you all here.
In fact this is a debate which is a need.
Unfortunately Pakistan has been divided in two sides
Love Bhutto or hate Bhutto
Many realities have been ignored due to this reason .
Now there is no active Bhutto
Unfortunately we could not produce any alternate
Only reason
Role of Establishment.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

They thought differently. Politically they were more advanced than West Pakistanis. They had their own language, spoken for centuries, and they had majority in population. So they revolt against imposing of Urdu on them. There was absolutely no problem being a bi-langual country. They ultimately succeeded in getting their own language after public demonstrations and killings.

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

ZAB becomes President in 1971 and you are telling me now?

Re: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Becomes Preisedent 1971

ahh never mind Robert sorry to make u a think