I am still sticking to my point.
why? because there is no databook or seerah book which lists the mahrems of mirza sahab?
You said she is not MEHRAM. Did you say that or not? I never started discussion on MEHRAM. Its you and Raheel. Thats what I am asking provide me proof that she was not MEHRAM.
if you try to pay more attention it is more like we are asking you whether she was his mahrem or not. I said so due to you people not providing any evidence for it. Why can't you produce an evidence to disapprove us? If my statment came out as an assertion then I rectify from it. But again I said so due to you NOT providing any evidence to remove the doubts and also because the context doesn't allow me to give him any benefit of doubt. I hope this clarifies a bit more.
I dont have GOD gifted sight which can read each every book and page and history on everything.
utter rubbish to say the least! How it is our fault if you haven't read your own books? Are you telling me you can't go and ask your scholars? Are you telling me you have no seerah book on mirza? SubhaanAllah, this is not even a century old incident and you are complaining about not having access to these documents which should be available and taught to every qadyani child. Look at us, allhamdulillha, we know the biography and relationship of important people to our Prophet (sal-allahu 'alayhi wa sallam). We have read and preserved his seerah and their biographies. But you can't even find a biography of single person and specially someone who served and looked after your prophet. It is amazing that you guys have no easily accessible book which lists the family and the mahrems of mirza sahab. I'm shocked and dumbfounded at your blunder!
In order to remove our doubts against your prophet, all you have to do is show us a text which says that she was his mahrem. It is as simple as that
I
please stop with your childish behaviour and stop attacking us - attack the arguments please. When you couldn't prove anything and this is what you come down to - hatred for none and love for all -
I have yet to expose you heretics liars for lying against the noble scholars of Islam in other thread. insha'Allah, I'll do once my research is complete and that will be very soon!