Yes I know we’ve discussed this but I am not looking for just recommendations…I want to know what your Holy Grail of mascaras is 
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
L'oreal power volume 24h mascara. No joke it makes my lashes look like I'm wearing falsies.
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Don't have a HG but I rotate between L'Oreal Voluminous Lashes in Carbon Black and L'Oreal Million Lashes WP but I have 3 mascaras coming in the mail (Armani Eyes to Kill, Maybelline Full 'n' Soft and Lancome Hypnose WP) so I will be reporting back.
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Max Factor False Lash Effect mascara. Been using it for years
Your HG Mascara :)
Lancôme Drama! Amazing wore it today for the first time Im loving it. Moved over from Dior blackout I really liked it always end up going back to that after I change but it dries out too quickly
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Hypnôse Drama by Lancome, only mascara that can make my lashes look good, no other mascara i've ever tried comes close.
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Dramatic: L'oreal Voluminous
Every day: Wet n Wild Protein Mascara.
Re: Your HG Mascara
my every day mascara that i’ve been using for over 10 years is Maybelline Full n’ Soft 
for evening i haven’t found that “perfect one” but i like L’Oreal Voluminous Million Lashes- i’ve tried a lot of expensive kinds (like DiorShow, Lancome Defencils, Hypnose, Hypnose Drama, Estee Lauder, Clinique) and find that drugstore mascaras work best for me
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Diorshow + Maybelline Volume Express..
I slightly prefer the Diorshow but the other one is brilliant for the price..
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
I love Diorshow mascara BUT the issue is it flakes after a bit. Its rumored to help with lash growth and I do see a difference but again...the flakiness is unattractive. I lovvvvvvve using it on my bottom lashes.
My go-to mascara is Loreal Voluminous...been using it since sophomore year of high school and there's always a tube of it in my purse even if I am trying out something else.
One I have heard is really good is Givenchy Noir Couture is amazing...any reviews?
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Benefit They're Real, just need one coat!
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Max Factor's False Lash Effect is my HG mascara. I've tried Diorshow and Lancome's Hypnose because of the rave reviews, but I just ended up going back to the Max Factor mascara.
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Loreal's telescopic mascara ... best.mascara.ever!!!!!
Your HG Mascara :)
I love my max factor false lash effect! I use any clumpy thick mascara and then finish off with max factor!
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
Loreal Million lashes!! Most loreal ones are brilliant! Diorshow is the only high end one I like but personally even that I don’t find is any better than the loreal ones!
At the moment im stuck with YSL false lash and its rubbish – started off really well but in about 2 weeks it’s gotten really dry and flaky – This morning I couldn’t even apply more than one coat! I always get taken in by the ads and big claims – such a sucker me!
Re: Your HG Mascara :)
For me Loreal Million Lashes as well. I have used many Loreals, false lash effect is good as well. but with this one, i really dont need any false lashes at all. it boosts the volume a lot.
Your HG Mascara :)
Bourjois one. The one that rotates