You Favourite Allrounders

Robert · August 11, 2006, 5:46pm

Its hard to be consclusive that who is the best. But among these 4, who are your favourite two

a. Abdul Razzaq
b. Shahid Afridi
c. Shoaib Malik
d. Naveed-ul-Hassan

My pick for ODI is Razzaq & Afridi,
For test is Malik & Hassan

Decent_6Chora · August 11, 2006, 6:08pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

hmmm so with Test avg or around 17.5 and ODI avg of around 15.4, Naved-Ul-Hasan is an all rounder?

Captain1 · August 11, 2006, 6:30pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

^ thats what we heard about him when he joined the squad i.e. all-rounder.

Captain1 · August 11, 2006, 6:31pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

I don't know how you came up with these names in ODIs or Tests. But Naved is more suited in ODI.

To me:
ODIs: S Malik, Afridi, Razzaq, Naved (more as bowler)
Tests: S Malik, Razzaq.

GoldenAsif · August 11, 2006, 6:37pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

Agree with captain1

Robert · August 11, 2006, 6:51pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

I think Razzaq is not as potent as Hassan, so I want Razzaq in ODI and Hassan in test. In the absense of any really potents bowlers, Hassan has not done too bad in tests.

Man_with_a_Plan · August 11, 2006, 6:52pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

I will put Shoaib Akhtar in place of Rana.

Captain1 · August 11, 2006, 7:14pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

Razzaq is good in batting but not as in bowling, inverse is true for Naved whose ODI bowling is far ahead of Razzaq. Both are mediocre in Tests (atleast in bowling) while Razzaq is ahead of him in batting.

smooth_guy · August 11, 2006, 7:21pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

Shoaib Malik in both forms of cricket. Rana in ODI. Afridi sometimes may be. Akhtar is not bad of an allrounder for Tests.

All_Rounder · August 11, 2006, 7:24pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

In test Afridi,Razzaq,Malik,rana , in ODIs Malik,Razzaq,Afridi,Rana , All Rounder

Robert · August 11, 2006, 7:43pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

ODI

Razzaq & Afridi, 2 votes
Malik, Afridi 1 vote
Malik, Hassan 1 vote

Test

Malik & Razzak 2 votes
Malik & Hassan 1.5 votes (smooth_guy's choice was Malik & Akhter)

fair_balance · August 12, 2006, 6:40pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

I will vot for my fav Md. Sami..

Please throw ande and tamatar with care.

SuperMe · August 12, 2006, 6:42pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

I thought we were talking about the world allrounders. Meaning your favourite ones.

World: Andrew (Freddie) Flintoff.
Pakistan: Abdul Razzaq.

acrobi123 · August 13, 2006, 2:06am

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

ODI:
1) Abdul Razzaq
2) Shahid Afridi and Shoaib Malik ( both are equal for me at 2nd best)

Test Match:
1) Abdul Razzaq
2) Shoaib Malik

P.S. Naveed should be in the bowler category.

Bholay_Bisray · August 13, 2006, 12:58pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

In 2005/06 (Test)

Afridi : Matches = 5 , Runs = 436, Av. 54,50 , Wickets = 9, Av = 39,97

Razzaq : Matches = 4 , Runs = 236, Av. 39,33 , Wickets = 13, Av = 32,53

Malik : Matches = 6 , Runs = 349, Av. 43,62 , Wickets = 5, Av = 55,80

Rana : Matches = 3 , Runs = 77, Av. 25,66 , Wickets = 8, Av = 39,75

In 2005/06 (ODI)

Afridi : Matches = 13 , Runs = 146, Av. 12,16 , Wickets = 13, Av = 28,30

Razzaq : Matches = 15 , Runs = 272, Av. 30,22 , Wickets = 9, Av = 52,11

Malik : Matches = 15 , Runs = 523, Av. 40,23 , Wickets = 9, Av = 36,11

Rana : Matches = 14 , Runs = 100, Av. 20,00 , Wickets = 22 Av = 27,68

so the winner is ?

Test : Afridi
ODI : Shoaib Malik

:)

GoldenAsif · August 13, 2006, 1:01pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

For ODIs Malik, Afridi and Razzaq

For test Malik and either Afridi or Razzaq

Rana is not an all-rounder....FULL STOP.

smooth_guy · August 14, 2006, 3:05pm

Re: You Favourite Allrounders

That just tells you how good Afridi is without brain. Imagine what can he do if he use his brain.