Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Arts & Culture Poetry ( Intikhaab & Sho'ra-e-Gupshup)
1

Shor Hai Ho Gaye Dunya Se Musalman Nabood
Hum Ye Kehte Hain Ke The Bhi Kahin Muslim Maujood!

Waza Mein Tum Ho Nisara, Tau Tamaddun Mein Hanood,
Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Yun To Syed Bhi Ho, Mirza Bhi Ho, Afghan Bhi Ho
Tum Sabhi Kuch Ho, Batao To Musalman Bhi Ho!

Stanza(17)
Jawab e shikwa

2

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

someone wrote that our syllabus is vaguely compiled that it doesn’t meet our requirements. One suggestion was to make it mandatory to remember jawab e shikwa by heart.

3

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

:k:

4

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

I don’t think so this kind of poetry can be included in syllabus.

5

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

^Itni sari poetry jo k samjh bhi.nahi thi wo intermediate mein rakh dety hain isi ko akeley he rakh dain tu kafi hojaiga..

6

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

but it should be…

7

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

I’ve hard many things taking out from the syllabus. Yes it should be but I think after Gen. Mushraf our syllabus have been totally changed.

8

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

syllabus should be changed on regular basis to include latest updates, but there should be some permanent parts like this type of poetry.

9

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Looks like Hanood and Yahood is written in as depreciating way as some Chura-Chamaar types :slight_smile:

10

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

No My Friend Its Not About Chura Chammar. Every one should concentrate or adopt their own religion and avoid to copy others. So Dr. Allama is saying that we have completely forget our religion and adopted the things even which are not allowed in Hindus / Jews.

11

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Thanks!! Any other good poems like Sach keh do ae baaman agar tu bura naa maane for my personal use :slight_smile:

12

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

I’ll post it in different thread “Nayya Shiwala”

13

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Not at all. It’s like when Bollywood goes out of its way to copy Hollywood.

14

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Its not about depreciation of others. Its about distinguished identity

15

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

Personal use? Champion ko chitawni deni hai :slight_smile:

16

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

It is used in tongue-in-cheek way :slight_smile:

Though if spoken it often incite her, but just like any other people of her tribe, she will take it and will attack only when time is right :slight_smile:

17

Re: Yeh Musalman Hain! Jinhain Dekh Ke Sharmaen Yahood?

:cb: