wrongly attributing kalaam to Ustaad sho'araas

[muqawwee123]

Re: wrongly attributing kalaam to Ustaad sho’araas

@Khalil KhaaN FaaKhta

^ ^^ wallaho 'aalam bissawaab!

JaaN Nisaar Akhtar par Khud yeh ilzaam lagaa thaa k vo apne gaaoN ke kisii gum-naam shaa’ir se gaane Khareed kar filmoN meN bechte the.

is par bhii main yehii kahuuNgaa k wallaho 'aalam bissawaab.

kia ham Zafar kii salaaHiyatoN par shak karte haiN yaa aayaa unhoN ne daanista taur par kisii aur kaa kalaam apne naam ke saath mansoob kar liyaa? aisaa to qata’ii nahiiN ho saktaa…haN, sahvan yaa qasdan kisii ne Zafar ke saath isko mansoob kar diyaa. vaise, Zauq ke hote huye aise Muztar jaise less-Known shaa’ir kaa kalaam kiuN shaamil kiyaa…yeh bhii ek sawaaliyah nishaan hai.

btw, Muztar saaHab kaa kalaam Khud ek mo’amma hai kiuN k unkaa kalaam sabhii gum ho chuke haiN to yeh shosha kahaN se chhoTaa?

Khair, jo bhii Haqeeqat rahii ho magar maiN Zafar ko is mo’aamile se qat’an mustasnaa kartaa huN…jis ne bhii kiyaa agar kuchh kiyaa to vo qaabil e mazammat hai.

Muztar wrote this Ghazal for movie ‘Laal Qila’. I don’t think that he lived during Bahadur Shah’s era