Re: Would you marry her?
^whats wrong with that. I wouldn't mind that either.
Re: Would you marry her?
Not a big issue in these days, nobody should be blame for others wrong doings.....
Re: Would you marry her?
I’d be marrying her and not her sister.
So NO that should not be a deciding factor even though I am sure this will be brought up at some point by parents or LOOG … 
Re: Would you marry her?
^whats wrong with that. I wouldn't mind that either.
nothing wrong with either but it feels that sometimes people are less judgmental when it comes to guys then girls
Re: Would you marry her?
^ Isn't that obvious. Women have more respect of their families associated with them as well as their actions than the men themselves?
I think D6C summed it up well in his post. Until and unless the woman had any major influence in what appears to be the case of a "Stubborn > Turned unfortunate family and their overtly adventurous of a daughter" I don't see a reason why anyone needs to denounce someone or their proposal based on what may have occurred in the past.
brb OP thinks all men are evil? :(
brb I get a legit reason to ask her to couch in to explain what exactly took place while she marches in with the tea trolley. :D
Re: Would you marry her?
I have only seen it on Bend it like Beckham.
Yes, I'd marry keira knightley
Re: Would you marry her?
^ Request to reconsider. Keira knightley holds nothing against the beauty of the chief ministers. 
Re: Would you marry her?
yes and why not
Re: Would you marry her?
No i would not.
Re: Would you marry her?
i would marry a guy whose brother or sister did that...it has no bearing on our relationship
Re: Would you marry her?
I'm just wondering....for those who say it has and shouldn't have any effect on your relationship..have you considered that when you have children, they may grow up thinking eloping or being with a non-Muslim is "ok"? or is that too far ahead in the futrue to think about.
Re: Would you marry her?
^They might do it anyway. The decisions your kids make are dependent more on the way you raise them, rather than what their uncles or aunts did.
Still there aren't any guarantees in life.
Re: Would you marry her?
^ True. I don't think this way....but I wonder if that's the concern of those who say they wouldn't...
Re: Would you marry her?
I don't think most people think that far. Family pressure and mental conditioning throughout their lives are at play here. As far as religion goes, Islam doesn't prohibit such a union, as far as the girl is religious enough. So the reason is more of a "log kia kehen ge" or "tarbiat kesi ki thee".