Would Muslims and Christians cremate their dead?

Give Serious Consideration to Cremation

Large areas of land in our countries are now being devoted to cemeteries containing permanent graves, and it is obvious that at some stage the process of every dead person having a freehold cemetery plot in perpetuity has to end.

At some stage significant percentages of India’s and Pakistan’s land surface will have to be devoted to such cemeteries and in theory there could come a time when the entire surface area of the country is needed.

Obviously something will happen long before these stages are reached. But there needs to be careful debate and careful thought over the options now.

The permanent grave plot is relatively new. While burial was universal among Islamic cultures, and graves were marked when dug, nature was allowed to take its course and over the decades graves were abandoned and forgotten. The dead returned to the earth and even if the site was dug over a few decades later, no identifiable remains could be found.

With a handful of exceptions, no one in India/Pakistan knows the location of the grave of an ancestor who died a hundred years ago.

So one option for India/Pak’s cemeteries might be recycling. Many crowded countries have taken this route and allowed a body to lie in a grave for a century, before any surviving remains were reverently gathered and the land reused.

Cremation has developed as an option in other lands. While some religions, such as Hinduism and the pre-Christian pagan religions of Europe, encouraged or demanded cremation, most monotheistic religions were opposed to the idea, some very strongly.

Cremation only started becoming a serious option in Europe in the 20th century, as cemeteries filled and funeral costs rocketed, and the Catholic Church, the largest single group of religious believers in the world, only allowed cremation in the 1960s following a serious theological investigation of just what was involved in cremation.

By the time the change was made many Catholic countries were facing serious problems in finding grave sites and ingenious solutions were in use, including huge walls of graves with the coffins stacked in many stories.

Cremation has the advantage that the remains are rotted very quickly in a fire, instead of slowly underground, and the dust that remains is compacted into a modest urn that can be buried.

More families should give serious consideration to cremation followed by a burial of the ashes and dust in individual marked graves.

This grave, small as it would be, could be marked with a stone and because so little land would be taken, would have a considerably better chance of being left alone forever.

You wrote it all yourself? Or is there a weblink, you forgot to give? :)

In any case, under proper Islamic method, there should be no coffin and no permanent grave. The body is wrapped in cloth and the grave should be just earth. After a few months, the body will probably decompose and the grave be used for another body. It is through this same method, that the most famous graveyard in muslim world - Jannat-al-Baqee - in Medina is able to accomodate countless muslims for hundreds of years with a fixed and relatively small area.

Point being, cremation is not the only solution. Its probably not even permitted under Islam. However, the solution to the question you raised is evidently very simple. :)

tch tch...how sick,
cremation is the worst way to dispose a human body.
it encourages air pollution and if you are talking about use of wood to burn it...it endangers our natural resouces, esp the forest.
not atall sensible. neither is coffinmaking.

^^ Yeah, I agree with soul...A body is nothing more than a discarded soul container...(No pun intended)...:D

At least when we bury the body it provides food for the worms, it provides nutrients to the soil, it doesn't stink up the place, no wood needed...So many benefits from a corpse...Why burn it up and waste all the good it has?

Hindus are also recommended to go for Electric cremation instead of traditional cremation using Wood. Using Wood adds pollution, also danger of cutting too many trees.

Electric Cremation is popular in big cities like Mumbai, Bangalore and Delhi.

ummmm!! power consumption over a corpse.
when there is scarcity of power for living beings.

than wot do you do with the ashes, pollute rivers.

tch! the whole reason i hate all religions, they reduce humans to pre programmed robots. Why cant you all think!

Btw Lajawab, there is no soul.

Geeezz! wot am i saying?