World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

After 8 years of economic mismanagement by Mushrraf and his corrupt cronies I hope the new govt take right steps to bring country out of economic mess.

http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5i0qDSNyevhARFJY0DWJ8fvEhEhZgD8VLQ9Q00

World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

By STEPHEN GRAHAM – 2 hours ago

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan (AP) — Pakistan’s new government must take urgent action to prevent the country’s economy from tipping into crisis, the World Bank warned Thursday.

Praful Patel, a vice president at the bank, said the South Asian country needs to make painful adjustments to higher global prices for oil, commodities and foodstuffs or risk a slowdown.

“There is not yet a crisis, but the economic picture for Pakistan is not good,” Patel said. “There is a good economic foundation, but the growth can only continue if Pakistan adjusts to the new global reality.”

Patel issued a statement after a three-day visit to Pakistan, which included talks with leaders of the new government taking power after eight years of military rule under President Pervez Musharraf.

Musharraf, who seized power in a 1999 coup, guided Pakistan from the brink of bankruptcy to multiyear economic growth.

A United Nations report released on Thursday said that Pakistan’s economy was expected to grow at 6.5 percent this year, despite uncertainty about stability in the country, which faces rising Islamic extremism and a bumpy transition back to democracy.

But some economists warn the current expansion is heavily reliant on a boom in consumer spending and money sent home by Pakistanis working abroad and that the country produces too few high-value exports.

In the short term, there is particular concern about the government’s rising budget deficit and a shortfall in the balance of payments. Both are putting downward pressure on the Pakistani currency, the rupee.

Patel noted that foreign investment and remittances have kept pace and that the stock market has posted gains. The Karachi Stock Exchange’s benchmark index closed at a record on Thursday.

However, he forecast that the government would miss its targets for the budget and current account deficits as well as for foreign exchange reserves.

The caretaker administration that left office this week had begun reducing subsidies on fuel prices that have bitten deeply into the government’s coffers. The new government must decide where to cut spending and is reportedly eyeing the military budget for possible reductions.

The World Bank said its team discussed changes in oil imports, taxation and “prioritization of expenditures.”

“Any adjustment will be painful,” said Patel. “But there must be an appropriate safety net for the poor.” He said that could include direct cash transfers, a mechanism used to relieve people hit by Pakistan’s massive 2005 earthquake.

Pakistan’s new prime minister, Yousaf Raza Gilani, is expected to announce steps to address the country’s problems, including high food prices and energy shortages, when he makes his first policy speech in parliament on Saturday.

“If action is not taken, the economy will start to falter, but with the right policies and strong support from multilateral and bilateral partners, we believe the high growth and poverty reduction path can be maintained in Pakistan,” Patel said.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Shamraz- You missed these lines in the article

"Musharraf, who seized power in a 1999 coup, guided Pakistan from the brink of bankruptcy to multiyear economic growth."

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Using two sentences to distort a whole article. :rolleyes:

The people of Pakisatn are not stupid. The election results show what the people of Pakistan think of Mush’s rule.

With nine years of absolute rule, with the billions that flowed in after 9/11, Mush had a golden opportunity to do something for Pak if he wasn’t so corrupt and power hungry.

What a shame

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Musharaff is corrupt? What makes you think that ?

By the way, its unethical to present an assumption as a fact.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

these people are just funny, they belive doubling GDP is called mismanagement :CareBear: i wonder what they call the bankrupt economy under nawaz shiriff, economic miricles:hehe: no wonder why they support nawa shirif

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Please point me to the lines in this article, which talk about Musharraf’s economic mismanagement. thanks

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Alhamdulilallah. God Bless President Musharaf for saving Pakistan and taking it on the path of Unprecedented Growth. Long may it continue. :k:

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Robert,

There you go.

[quote]
There is not yet a crisis, but the economic picture for Pakistan is not good," Patel said.
[/quote]

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Same you can say about US economy rightnow. But where does it say that Musharraf mismanaged it. The article actually seems to praise his role.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Robert,

I don't believe in these nonsense reports which can go both ways.:) Wait for the new finance minister to capture the actual economic picture. What I know that common person in Pakistan is not happy with the present economic policies. On an average, daily a person commits suicide due to un-employment depicts not so good situation.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

lets see how this article states that

prevent..i.e. its not in crises, but it can get in crises…now lets see ..why it can tip into crises

ahhh global increase in prices…dunn think Pakistan being’mismanaged’ will have global impact on prices of oil and food..

[quote=““Shamraz Khan””]

so

  1. good economic foundation (somehow it doesnot make me think of economic mismanagement)
  2. growth can only continute if.. ( meaning there is growth, kewl.. does not sound too bad)
  3. Pakistan needs to adjust to the new global reality ( so its global in scale, thus not an economic mismanagement of pakistan, its new, meaning it was not a factor 8 until recently, and ‘djust’ means changes have to be made.

Damn it…how darehe mismanage economy and thus guide it from brink of bankruptcy to multiyear economic growth…

shame shame, growth is bad…lets go back to brink of bankruptcy..damn economic mismanagement…bringing us growth and shyt..we dunn need no stinkin growth..

so it has not faltered yet,
growth can be maintained i.e. there has been growth
poverty reduction can be maintained meaning there has been poverty reduction.

damn…what bad ad economic mismanagement…

(the issues with balance of payments and state of our industry not withstanding, but especially for industries ppl need to realize that govt handouts and protection only take you so far, if youa re not comeptitive you get messedup.. UK saw it, US saw it Japan saw it..steps need to be taken to sort that but it has to be a govt and industry partnership and not some nationalized mills and factories like that genius pinata boy came up with in his era)

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Yes, what a shame, you have agreed to disagree no matter what and this usually happens when you close your eyes and live in a make belief world of your own .One should be decent enough to realise that Musharraf has done a lot and steared this country from years of Bankruptcy and bad governance.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Unbelievable. These people were trying to use this article to prove that Musharraf destroyed pakistan's economy. After reading the article they realized it never said that. So now its a nonsense article for them.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

I can't see where the article puts any blame on Musharraf. Infact if you can read between the lines it said it says that the precedent that has been set by the government needs to continue OTHERWISE things could become bleak.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Sir, how is the government supposed to get people employed if we do things in our country to scare off all the investors who would create employment opportunities for such people. The other alternative is the government can squeeze more taxes from people and give them off to welfare, would you like to see that?

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

unless there was more substance/backup to the article posted here, I don't see any substance. because it says:

Remittance is strong and will continue to be
Growth has been strong and no signs it won't continue
Political system is mending

Only negative they talk about is the budget deficit. Tell me which growing economy doesn't resort to that?

Oil price is up globally - in fact Pakistan gets subsidy from suppliers I think.

So I just don't see what and where the big risk perception comes from (ie without considering the jihadi problem which is what I think the risk is)

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Good analysis.

I know majority of the people in Pakistan are worried about ever increasing inflation but over the last five years I have seen only increase in number of factories in the area where I work.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Thats I think is key word here, Pakistan must take action to prevent stepping into crisis.

Now that is scary part if true, IMO.

As Stircrasy pointed, its all talk without facts/numbers, more like ‘gossip’.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

Alhamdulilallah. A very positive article indeed about Pakistan economy and the very good foundation that has been laid. I am sure the new govt. would capitalize on this.

Re: World Bank: Pakistan Risks Crisis

^^First of all this unprecendeted economic growth has zero tickle down effect. Life of common man has deteriorated in all these years. Mover over this so called improvement is due to lifting of ban by Uncle Sam after involving in war against terror and inducting billions in economy. I don't know why you give credit to Mush for this? In this scenario, had a donkey been president, economy would have the same results.:D