SIGHHH.. yar had ho gayee.
Nescio, the ahadith about using the siwak actually mention orders of the Prophet. That using the siwak has a REWARD. The ahadith here are ‘advices’. Not orders. Can you spot the difference or is that asking for too much?
PA,
I never said the hadith were weak/fabricated or whatever. The ‘context’ I talk about is what I’ve gathered by looking at the questions. people asked simple questions, about the afterlife, about sex, about their tribes. The questions dont have too many loopholes or are long complicated questions. We get a general idea of their train of thought.
Did nothing of that sort. Dont daydream.
The hadith literature is not bound to the particular century because it contains explanations by the Prophet over daily issues, as the Quran explicity tells us that the messenger will explain to us the verses. What you guys state are their daily affairs taken out of context.
Arabic is a different language, the metaphor usage is very high. We can not attempt to understand a language by looking at its literal TRANSLATION which you’ve done here. Calling someone an ulloo means we’re insulting him, at the same time at places this same owl is considerd a sign of wisdom. O mere bhai literal translation just does not convey the exact meaning baat ko samjha karo.
whats your point?
I said nothing about the ahadith being saheeh or not!! yar do you even read what i write??? I JUST SAID THAT NOT ALL AHADITH IN THE SAHEEHAYN ARE CORRECT!! It is NOT UPON ME TO GO AND CHECK WHATEVER YOU POST. THE ABOVE AHADITH CAN EASILY BE, AND MOST PROBABLY ARE SAHEEH. that was a side remark that not all are saheeh. ayee aqal mayn?? (writing in caps to emphasize just so you can get the point)
Enough of this debate.. those who wanted to draw their conclusions can do so from the above.
