Peace CAorMBA
Let’s make it more pragmatic for you.
I personally have no reason to doubt the birth of Imam ALi (AS) in the ka’bah, until I find other sources to say otherwise. For me it is not an article of my faith - aqeedah to believe this happened or not.
However, I do not believe that:
a) Every year the crack reopens - to prove this you need to show me a picture of the closed crack and then each new year crack - that is 2 new pictures for each year 1 when it reopens and 1 when it is fixed. If you cannot show me these pictures ranging over 10 years then I cannot believe this claim. More importantly I need a picture on the day of the birthday of Imam Ali (RA) or a video of the crack forming on his (RA) birthday to believe this claim.
ANS:According to my source,the miracle is that crack cant be closed regarding how much you try.therefore there is no point that it reopens every year.A crack which is not closed how comes it opens every year.therefore i dont agree with this.
b) I do not believe that the Saudis cover this crack to hide the miracle - you need to prove that also.
ANS:here you can see many pics of the crack of the Holy Kaba, at different times, when different methods has been used to cover the crack on the Holy Kaba, notice how different colored stones and different nails have been used in different pictures…
http://www.valiasr-aj.com/fa/page.php?bank=khabar&id=315
c) I don’t believe that the crack keeps happening to prove who is right or wrong either, because no such thing happens for proving to non-Muslims who is right or wrong so why should something happen to prove to sub-groups of Muslims that someone is right or wrong? Furthermore, I can still believe if I wanted to that Imam Ali(RA) was born in the ka’bah as you claim, but at the same time deny that the crack is a miracle, where do I fit then?
Ummm i dont know where you fit,if you believe that HAZRAT ALI A.S was born in KAABA you are believing the truth but if you deny that the crack is miracle,i challenge you to go and close that crack or ask saudi government to close that crack.