It seems my post fell on deaf ears … or is it ‘blind eyes’?
Anyway …
A crack in a very old wall/rock is bound to occur … it is the principle of erosion
ANS:FIRST OF ALL,WALL OF KAABA IS NOT OLD ITS RECONSTRUCTED BY SAUDI GOVERNMENT BUT THAT SPECIFIC PART OF WALL OF KAABA NEVER BEING CLOSED,WHICH YOU WILL SAY A MYSTERY LOL.http://www.aulia-e-hind.com/Qiswa.htm
Fixing a crack in a wall is done to stop the problem escalating so the whole thing doesn’t falls in on itself. It is not necessarily done to hide a miracle.
ANS:OK,I AGREE BUT IF YOU CANT FIX A CRACK FOR 1400 YEARS,WHAT WILL YOU CALL IT.
Why would a crack need to form anyway? The birth has already taken place there is no need for the crack to reopen only to be fixed again. If this crack really did happen then it needed to be done only once, there is no need for it to be repeated. Ever heard of any other miracle repeating?
ANS:WHY WOULD A CRACK NEED TO FORM ANYWAY:TO BE A SIGN OF PROOF OF HAZRAT ALI (A.S) BIRTH IN KAABA FOR LATTER PEOPLE LIKE U WHO EVEN DONT ADMIT IT WHEN ITS THERE.
What has the crack to do with the birth anyway. It has nothing to do with it. The ka’bah was opened and accordingly the shi’ah sources say that the ka’bah was lived in for 3 days. This is complete darkness in a very hot cuboid without food, water and a collection of idols. Not a very nice place to be in for that time. However, the story may turn out that the whole scenery was different and it was not dark but light, no idols they were all made invisible, not hot but a cool wind was there and food and water were given too. Perhaps that is the full story. If it isn’t there then you can reference my creative thoughts if you like.
ANS:WE DONT NEED YOUR CREATIVE THOUGHTS,IF ALLAH CAN GIVE FOOD TO HAZRAT YOUNAS IN THE STOMACH OF FISH AND BIBI MARYAM BY GROWING A TREE BESIDE HER ONLY PEOPLE LIKE U CANT DOUBT ALLAH’S POWER AND HIS WILL.
The story also says that the “holy books” were mentioned and that Muhammad (SAW) spoke to the mother (RA). All this had to be done before prophethood of Muhammad (SAW). Rather remarkable story since this must have been the first time Muhammad (SAW) spoke of any knowledge with authority of the ghaib because other traditional stories claim that it happened later when he (SAW) was meditating in the cave. Yes, wonderful things happened to Muhammad (SAW) throughout his life, but he didn’t speak with any authority about them until his prophethood. (SAW).
ANS:THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN UR SECT AND OUR THAT U DUMB PEOPLE CONSIDER HAZRAT MOHAMMAD S.A.W.W PROPHET AFTER HIS FORTY YEARS OF AGE AND WE CONSIDER HIM THE PROPHET WHEN NOTHING WAS CREATED BY ALLAH EXCEPT HAZRAT MOHAMMAD S.A.WW.WELL ANYTHING CAN BE EXPECTED FROM U PEOPLE WHO SAY THAT HAZRAT JIBRIEL CAME AND TOLD EVERYTHING TO THE HAZRAT MOHAMMAD WHO DIDNT KNOW ANYTHIING,MEANS HAZRAT JIBRIEL WAS BETTER IN KNOWLEDE THAN HAZRAT MOHAMMAD S.A.W.W(TOBA ASTAGFAR).
WE BELIEVE THAT HAZRAT MOHAMMAD S.A.WW WAS ALLOWED TO DECLARE THAT HE IS PROPHET AT THE AGE OF FORTY AND SINCE HE KNEW FROM THE BEGINNING THAT HE IS A PROPHET HE PRAISED MOTHER OF HAZRAT ALI(A.S) BIBI AMNA.