Why are Muslims against Evolution?!?

[psyah]

Re: Why are Muslims against Evolution?!?

@yazdi

@psyah

Thanks for adding the emoticon to my quote.. and actually depicting my emotions which otherwise I would have felt too impolite to add..!!!

Let the readers decide what can be concluded from your post 540 when you said “So Theorist … please show us speciation in the making … hmm … I forgot … you’re only a theorist .”

You claim to be a science scholar.. you know what, I really believe you that you are not so naive about the concept of evolution.. I however fail to understand your motive when you asked why speciation/evolution does not occur due to inter racial cross breeding when you exactly know that this concept is totally against the concept of evolution (read Allopatric speciation from my post 574).. and then to ridicule the poor poster.. can you explain your exact motive for this kind of behavior..!!!

I feel you are now running away from the discussion.. as you really don’t have anything logical to add.. all your arguments are exposed to the readers.. which are highly biased to prove your other than scientific stance.

Okay to move the discussion further let me apologize if that will satisfy for this point.. now can you answer the other questions I have raised.. or you are stuck with another mantra of “first thing first” to avoid further embarrassment..!!!

Peace yazdi

Instead of trying to interpret what I am saying by “what did he mean by writing this” approach … think scientific and see that your accusation about me saying

**

Your first claim was that speciation can not occur under any circumstances whatsoever

**..in this post …

Is totally unfounded … then you spin off unfounded remarks to draw unfounded conclusions … there is absolutely no chance that I implied that speciation cannot occur … because I do believe that humans can interfere with nature and hence we can create situations that nature may not otherwise create for itself … So as long as you realise that I do not believe that speciation is impossible then we can move on …

Now the question to ask is since speciation is technically possible where has it happened … and you say it has happened in the hybridzation experiments … however are the findings from hybridization experiments a fair test for evolution? Is speciation actually occurring? And I say that they are not fair tests … I say this because hybridzation is not the process of evolution … to see my idea of a fair test for evolution go to this post …

To add insult to injury you go on and say this …

**

I think you don’t understand the concept of evolution. You are trying to give impression to the readers that evolution claims that monkeys gave birth to humans and speciation occurred,

**in this post

Actually I never gave this impression … This is what you are casting on me … I understand evolution … it appears you do not … I have mentioned the common ancestor theory here many times … So humans and Chimpanzees have a common ancestor … it begs the question could we come from that ancestor? So we came from something that no longer exists … but how do we check that we came from them? - There is no way to check for this because they are all dead. There is no way to prove it or disprove it … hence it is a belief. This common ancestor was single gene pool and allegedly it split in two groups that separately evolved … so there is one gene pool that becomes two … unfortunately the common ancestor remains are fossils and fossils are like rock - they no longer contain any DNA that we can ascertain any notion of parenthood. This is not to say that I am suggesting that humans came from monkeys … to say that would be old school evolution - new school evolution is more clever with the common ancestor there is no way to prove that wrong. A theory that cannot be proven wrong and not proven right is a belief.