Sara we did the same. When we went on our honeymoon, i showed my MIL where all the jewelry was kept too (i keep things at home so i can wear whenever i want). It just didnt occur to me to do otherwise. Now i cannot remember what happened on my wedding day or how i brought it to my husband’s house but i dont think my ammi gave it to MIL. Mostly becuz they were staying in a hotel and our place was much safer.