Who broke the idols in Mekkah? (Split from nawasa thread)

wow!! what a productive conversation!
will that make a tinny bit a difference in idealogy behind breaking the idols? I guess not!
so why acting like bunch of w*****s! shouldn't we talk about the reasons behind! or we are some of those who talk about the events not about the ideas!

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by ThandyMazaq: *

dont know what to say...enough for me, i wont get in shai sunni debates any longer for i dont even consider them muslims any more to get in debates with
lakum deno kum wila deen....
[/QUOTE]

And on what bases don't you consider them muslims Mr.

Don't shia prays 5 times a day,
Don't they believe in the day of judgement,
Don't they give zakat?
Don't they do hajj
and other wajibat-e-Deen....

Who are you to judge others Iman...when you yourself gave me an interpretatino of ayat and when I asked you questions to justify it...not one but several times... you didnt have any answer rather than twisting the argument to insult the daughter of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. when you can't even defend your own views and idea I asked you several questions but you didn't have an answer too.. and now you claim us nauzubillah non musilms... without any justification... what and how on what bases are you jumping to your conclusions....

A person doubting the Prophet hood of Mohammad P.B.U.H. when there are so many mauziays done by other Ambiya as I mention in one of my posts earlier in this thread... and its just hard for him to believe a 63 old man can lift 33 year old...... when so many abmiya has shown different maujizay.

an other person doubts Bibi fatima...respects the enemies of Ahleybait and people who offended Prophet... didnt even bother to attend the funeral services of Prophet...

I don't know what I think of you two guys?

I would appreciate if you could let me know how did you jump to the conclusion of nauzibillah shias being non muslims..when during previous conversations it seems like you don't even have t he knowledge to defend your own views.