Whats Your Verdict?

This is a strange story, if you want to read in detail.
http://www.crimelibrary.com/notorious_murders/family/yvonne_chevallier/index.html

Briefly,

Yvone a nurse falls in love with medial student Chevallier, they get married and have two children. Chevallier is handsome, social and respected for services he rendered during French resistance of German occupation. Yvone is an ordinary house wife without much charm.

Chevallier has an affair with a beautiful young woman (who happens to be married too). Yvone begs Chevallier to stop the affair and save their marriage, Chevallier says she disgusts her and he is not ineterested in her. Yvone shots dead Chevallier.

She is tried and jury acquits her.

My question: If you were in the jury what would be your verdict?

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

given the details, if islamic jury he was suppose to have this punishment anyway, but wife doesnt have right to kill him. she should get punishment not murder but slightly less like 10 years in jail.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

No matter what she has no right to take a life. She wasn't defending her own life or anything either. So I think she is guilty. Life for Life.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

how is she guilty? i think that cheater husband is guilty..and yes very well deservd...these men have no right to live a gud quality life...
and if he can cheat on his caring loving wife..woh bhi after a love marriage..she gt all right to do that...
however she should be punished...but not for murder....

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

Ok so lets replace that guy with this lady ... Think for a second that this lady cheated on him and he killed her ...

Will your opinion be same ?

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

Wow, citrine, it's rather disturbing that you think the way you do. You think that she has a right to kill him because he cheated on her and doesn't find her attractive anymore? Holy Moses, you know how many murders we would be dealing with if that were in fact not grounds for a guilty verdict? She could have divorced him and gone on her own way, but to kill him? WOW, remind me not to pi$$ YOU off ever. I like how tolerant you are.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

yes! co z i dnt think women can cheat....they hve a soft weak heart and they knw hw to love their partners

but men are pigs namy boi!

well wht kind of arguement is that....he didnt find her attractive anymore so he cheated on her....so why did he got married to her on the first place?
i can never tolerate with a cheater...they deserve hell

abb saray teray jasay Cheetay tu nahi hotay na :D

But seriously its more about killing a HUMAN then killing a man or woman. Humanity is priceless, don't let it die so easily.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

yea ..dont do these harkatein then

Great, now you are going around judging who does and doesn't deserve hell. Don't go around sitting on your high morality horse and then preach that it's OK to KILL someone. I'm not suggesting that what the guy did was OK, in fact it's deplorable, but it is also deplorable for you to condone murder.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

yea right.....he deserves it so he is dead today! end of discussion

Wow, "he deserves it, end of discussion", what madrasah did you learn you talibani at?

on the same line, i fully support honor killings bcos most involves wives cheating on their hubbies. :chai:

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

so yea ur one of these typical men who supprts honor killing...gud for u......
.i will repeat again wives dont cheat ..they r too innocent and soft to do anything like that....its basically how men take the whole situation

Lets not generlize things way too much .. both married men and women can do such type of things ..

yeah i’m more than those typical men who supports honor killings and i already know its good for me. :chai:

as for women being too innocent and soft…shove this nonesense down the throat of someone who was born yesterday.

Re: Whats Your Verdict?

:D

Most men are cheating with women aren't they? This is a bizarrely biased way to approach the issue.

She had every right to be mad, but not to kill.