Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
Do you really think negotiations with them could be a success?
You asked this question from me but I don't lead a political party. Imran does. And besides his all-the-time criticism, the only solution he gives for Taliban issue is "negotiations".
Hence the question: What will he do if the negotiations fail?
Let me use your own words to reply to your question: no guppy here leads the PTI, Imran Khan and his team does.
You are saying as if rest of the world has found any solution other than drone bombing.
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
Let me use your own words to reply to your question: no guppy here leads the PTI, Imran Khan and his team does.
That's true. And this is why I asked what Imran says about it. I did not ask your own opinion.
So after he is done with criticizing govt, after he is done explaining why negotiations are the ONLY way out for us; did he ever say what he will do if negotiations fail?
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
u want to end this war or want continuous bloodshed on BOTH sides? that is the question we should ask ourselves.
if u want peace, u got sit and talk. remember, the main reason they attack you is because u support the unjust war in afghanistan while cooperating with the evil empire. the soon u realise that fact the soon u attain peace..
there is no war on terror, it's a WAR, u suffer the casualties when u invade and aid invasion. take head out of sand and wake up. u r not angels who deserve peace in response to bombing others, u will get bombs in return. its how the world works.
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
That's true. And this is why I asked what Imran says about it. I did not ask your own opinion.
So after he is done with criticizing govt, after he is done explaining why negotiations are the ONLY way out for us; did he ever say what he will do if negotiations fail?
Point is... since PTI leadership doesn't exist here you need to address this question directly to them, may be PTI website will help instead of asking around everyone else.
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
PTI leadership does not exist but PTI supporters do. But it is interesting you raise this point because what leaderships of other parties exist here? If their non existence is reason enough to stop discussion about them then why are we discussing politics here?
Your above argument is a way to run away from the question.
Neither PTI website nor any of Imran's interviews have this question answered. Because this question exposes the stupidity of Imran's criticism of fight against Taliban.
People should know Imran's position before giving him their support. But unfortunately people just follow him because they like his criticism. They don't know that he gives NO solutions for the criticisms he make. And the solutions he does offer, like negotiations, SUCK big time.
Imran says that the ONLY way to stop terrorism is to negotiate with them. But has he ever said what these negotiations will look like, and what he will do if they fail?
Has any of his supporters given a thought that if negotiations fail then Pak would have to do exactly what it is doing today?
So why criticize current strategy so harshly if Imran eventually may end up doing the same thing?
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
What will Imran haters do if negotiations are success?
You asked this question from me but I don't lead a political party. Imran does. And besides his all-the-time criticism, the only solution he gives for Taliban issue is "negotiations".
Hence the question: What will he do if the negotiations fail?
That's true. And this is why I asked what Imran says about it. I did not ask your own opinion.
So after he is done with criticizing govt, after he is done explaining why negotiations are the ONLY way out for us; did he ever say what he will do if negotiations fail?
PTI leadership does not exist but PTI supporters do. But it is interesting you raise this point because what leaderships of other parties exist here? If their non existence is reason enough to stop discussion about them then why are we discussing politics here?
Your above argument is a way to run away from the question.
Neither PTI website nor any of Imran's interviews have this question answered. Because this question exposes the stupidity of Imran's criticism of fight against Taliban.
Now read red highlighted response of yours to my question. My question was to YOU and you ran away "I am not political leadership", but you are asking question which should be answered by PTI leadership on a forum where there is no known PTI representative. If you really were sincere then you would post it on their website, or approach media journalists when they interview him they can ask the question to him. But somehow you figured out a question which you think will expose Imran's stupidity you are thumping your chest here which I believe is of no use. Its like running around in jungle shouting and asking where is the guru who can answer my questions.
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
Captain:
[quote]
but you are asking question which should be answered by PTI leadership on a forum where there is no known PTI representative.
[/quote]
This simple question is not answered by Imran nor is thought of by any of his supporters. There is no reason to ask this question from Imran Talibani's representatives. The answer is obvious. If negotiations fail then current war against Talibanic terrorism will have to be continued. There is no other option.
The point of asking this question was to show that while Imran will criticize and abuse everyone eliminating the Taliban scum, he will eventually end up doing the same thing.
Re: What will Imran do if negotiations with Taliban fail?
I don't know if he was sincere, but Imran said that he wanted to continue the WoT (of course after leaving from US WoT) on Eliot Spitzer's CNN program. Now, we can't know for sure since he was against blasphemy law abuses but then someone on the forum posted how a PTI representative in a lahori mullah gathering said that blasphemy law is above discussion i.e. it is perfect as it is.
There is a reason young teenagers support imran khan and it is evident on this forum as well.