What should be the Islamic punishment of false character assassination?

[Faisal]

Exactly.

[Diva4U]

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by DiYa: *

All those who were sharing there thoughts at feed back must be ofline:) i guess

and i was wondering how to stop this war..
to hear that u are not Ahmadi

And what exactly is the meaning of this ??? Is this discrimination or not in your eyes ?

[M]

*Originally posted by Faisal: *
When Mr Salman can go around posting threats to slit people’s throats, accusing people of being something they are not, and insulting whole groups of people non-stop, he practically deserves everything that comes his way, and more. This is just the start, actually

Nice to see moderators acting in such a mature and tolerant manner. What a great example to set :k:

Still, I dont understand what the religious discussion is here, so why is it in this forum?

*Originally posted by Faisal: *
I think Islamically he should be punished as a liar and bearing false witness. Whats the punishement for that again?

Was he really bearing false witness? (its not like he was testifying in court) wasnt it more slander?

Anyway Ive already answered there is no islamic state or islamic court. So hence no Islamic punishment can be carried out.

[DiYa]

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Diva4U: *

Originally posted by DiYa: *

All those who were sharing there thoughts at feed back must be ofline:) i guess

and i was wondering how to stop this war..
to hear that u are not Ahmadi

And what exactly is the meaning of this ??? Is this discrimination or not in your eyes ?

i just felt GR8 that why..and cant stop feeling good about some one if he is not …Ahmadi..cuze i belive its worng..and dont wana say ..any thing about them.but
i just dont like them SIMPLE

[Sohaib]

So salman got his stats now?

[S02]

Disagreeing with someone's beliefs is fine. Insulting them is unacceptable.

But I agree with M, this discussion doesn't belong in this forum (or any forum?). Seems more of a personal discussion.

[DiYa]

*Originally posted by Sahar02: *
Disagreeing with someone’s beliefs is fine. Insulting them is unacceptable.
But I agree with M, this discussion doesn’t belong in this forum (or any forum?). Seems more of a personal discussion.

NO ITS NOT when it comes to :saw: it cant be personal
i guess

[system]

*Originally posted by Faisal: *
When Mr Salman can go around posting threats to slit people’s throats, accusing people of being something they are not, and insulting whole groups of people non-stop, he practically deserves everything that comes his way, and more. This is just the start, actually

I think Islamically he should be punished as a liar and bearing false witness. Whats the punishement for that again?

Haha its funny how you are defending your stupid post. But thats ok. I admit that lately I am being a bad boy, no doubt about that.

Umm thanx for bringing up slashing throats part. Umm I said that 6 months or more ?

But yes I thin… actually I strongly believe I should say, that a person should be killed if he/she continously keeps on disrespecting prophet Mohammad :saw: and by any means he/she does not stop, the ** the very last resort** should be to kill him.

A person like Salman Rushdi :saw: Should and MUST be killed for writing a book like **Rangeela Rasool **.

he practically deserves everything that comes his way, and more. This is just the start, actually

Thanx for talking like a 4 years old kid. I am not too sure about bearing witnesses because I never said anything about witnesses. As for people who are either mods/admins and have very close ahmedi friends who have always defended their believes, I will send you a list rite here in this forum with examples.

Only then you will know who is a liar and who doesn’t know anything.

Ciao
-Salman

[Diva4U]

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Sahar02: *
Disagreeing with someone's beliefs is fine. Insulting them is unacceptable.

^^^ The first sensible thing said all day today !!! Hallelujah !! Rejoice...

[S02]

Originally posted by DiYa: *

NO ITS NOT when it comes to :saw: it cant be personal
i guess

That’s true. But I didn’t see any place that the Prophet SAW was insulted. Perhaps I missed something.

[Muslim_Queen]

Honestly now guys you're all way off topic.First of all Faisal as much as I think you might have a point (which I no longer am so sure about)- is your thread not also about a few members.yeah its in the name of Islam.But this was something you needed to resolve in private with Salman and other members concerned.You didnt have to drag the forum into your argument.Honestly just pm each other and patch things up.Here you are bringing religion into a personal argument and getting everybody else involved too.What would happen if everybody started a post such as this- about something another member might have said against them.Come on you're a mod.I think religion forum should b kept for discussions.

Salman you and Faisal need to cool off. No wonder new non Muslims think Islam is full of hatred.Just look at the two of you.

[DiYa]

I agree with him at somepoints

[Faisal]

Trust Mr M to try and get Salman out of the mess he creates himself. Now that he has been proven as a liar and slanderer, you are coming out to say "it is not mature to attack him". Right. Attacking other people and making threats against them is only reserved for Salman. And then when they reply back he runs to Feedback complaining why others are not banned cz they are insulting his faith.

Anyway, hopefully Salman has learnt his lesson to only dish out what he can take in, and that to only open his mouth when he knows what he is saying. And since he has now disappeared from this discussion, lets close this for now.

If he still has questions on who is an Ahmadi and how many are there, he should contact the nearest religous police station.

ps. By the way, I have no wish to talk to him in a PM. He slandered people in the open and deserved to be replied back in public. The reason this thread was opened separately was because I didn't want to ruin S&T mod's welcome thread.