What Islamic Ummah?

Re: What Islamic Ummah?

Yet you accuse me of being insincere and dishonest in my search for truth.

Daesh is implementing their version of Islam and to them that is the truth. They probably think that your version of Islam is wrong. Who decides which Islamic knowledge is correct, Daesh’s, Salafi, Hanafi, Sufi, Maliki, Shafi, Shia, Ahmedi? Removing religion from government is a far simpler solution.

Ghamidi sounds fairly sane but he is regarded as a heretic by my many mainstream Islamic scholars. I’d take his version of Islam over others if there getting away from religion wasn’t an option. However, secular government would be the end goal, the ideal.