What is your horoscope?

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@ImranQ

Sharaabi bhai: aik main he nahi, angle eyes bhi aur dosray keh rahain hain kay asking for zodiac sign and there general characterstics is by no means haram.

Are horoscopes and zodiac signs … not astrology?

aap, angel eyes or doosrey keh rahe hai na, Saari duniya kahe astrology or any branch of astology is not haraam, i would not believe. Because that hadeeth of the Prophet said it all clearly, that any part of astrology is forbidden.

[shoaib_akhter]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@~Whispering Death~

means ur always bull***** tin

no ..

[danial]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@AnGeL EyEs

chatting on the phone or in person with the opposite sex w/o a mahram present is haraam…so what makes chatting online any different than the phone.

there is a verse that states…“whenever a man and a woman are alone together the third party is shaitan”

i’m not sure of the exact verse number but can find it for u all if need be.

fatwas are given when somwthing isnt stated clearly in the quran/hadiths…or when their needs 2 be a ruling on current issues that nvr existed in previous ages such as the net.

in this case isnt the third party the mod;s. are you calling them shaitan.

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@AnGeL EyEs

there is a verse that states…“whenever a man and a woman are alone together the third party is shaitan”

I dont think me and you are together rite now. That verse was meant for people physically together.

[danial]

Re: What is your horoscope?

just asking,

anyone knows how we got to this point, from a simple "What is your horoscope?"

[ImranQ]

Re: What is your horoscope?

angle eyes: chill out, don't create an issue out of nothin..

I cannot here you voice, I cannot see your face, even if i want to i cannot involve physically with you or anybody on GS so, how come there is a worry for committing a sin.

no worry of sin .... no haram. Isn't it??

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@ImranQ

sharaabi bahi, haram haram ki rat na lagao yaar, we are not talking about predictions here and are not trying to alter our lives according to astrology so, plz. stop make us feel like we have done some haram thing, chill out buddy

no haram here just halaal

.

I dont know how a muslim can make such a statement after reading this hadeeth:

Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever learns anything of astrology has learned a branch of witchcraft (al-sihr)…”

aur phir saath daant bhi nikaltey hai. Subhanallah.

anyways iam out, iv spoken enough on this topic. aagay Allah hidayat deney wala hai.

[shoaib_akhter]

Re: What is your horoscope?

can u guys plz stop dis nonsense… PLZZ guys

if u really wanna talk abt dis stuff, open another thread in religion…

[ImranQ]

Re: What is your horoscope?

sharaabi bahi, astrology is accepted by isalm as a valid brach of science, How can you say its harram ?? just desn't make sense..

[mAd_ScIeNtIsT]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@AnGeL EyEs

there is a verse that states…“whenever a man and a woman are alone together the third party is shaitan”

There is no verse like that. There is a hadith that states that. And how can you be alone with someone when you are far apart from them???

[_WiCcA_PrInCeSs]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@shoaib akhter

no ..

no need to cry u know its tru

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@ImranQ

sharaabi bahi, astrology is accepted by isalm as a valid brach of science, How can you say its harram ?? just desn’t make sense..

I think you talking about astronomy.

Astorology and Astronomy are two different fields of study.

Astronomy: the study of objects and matter outside the earth’s atmosphere and of their physical and chemical properties

Astrology: the divination of the supposed influences of the stars and planets on human affairs and terrestrial events by their positions and aspects

[ImranQ]

Re: What is your horoscope?

Sharabi yaar, don't be angry, stick to this thread and convince us or get convinced.. otherwise their is no point in argumenting,,

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

Astronomy allowed,

Astrology not allowed...

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@ImranQ

Sharabi yaar, don’t be angry, stick to this thread and convince us or get convinced.. otherwise their is no point in argumenting,

iam not angry..

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@shoaib akhter

can u guys plz stop dis nonsense… PLZZ guys

So performing, Amr bil ma’roof wa nahi an alMunkar (to adjoin good and forbid evil) is nonsese ???

Mashallah…

[ImranQ]

Re: What is your horoscope?

Astrology: the divination of the supposed influences of the stars and planets on human affairs and terrestrial events by their positions and aspects

sharabbi, we are not discussing influences of stars on human affairs or future predictions but just who born under which sign and what are there general behaviours or tendencies are... nothin else

[AnGeL_EyEs]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@Sharaabi

I dont think me and you are together rite now. That verse was meant for people physically together.

well when that verse came about there were no such things as internet and the phone..so the only thing we can go on are fatwas correct?

fatwas are not found in the quran or hadiths …agreed?

ok so we go by what scholars of this day have to say on issues that nvr took place back than like birth control (ie, tubal ligation, visectomy etc) or other issues of the sort like internet marriages etc…correct?

well based on the scholars of today…like mufti ibrahim desai who is a well known scholar of our time rules (along with other scholars) that it is prhibited to chat online with the opposite gender…

http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam/view.php?q=7707
http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam/view.php?q=12381
http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam/view.php?q=6277
http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam/view.php?q=59

[Sharaabi]

Re: What is your horoscope?

^^ well thats what astrology is. Astrology has been forbidden, period. The hadith showed it clearly.

If you wanna study general human behaviour, do it through physical sciences. Using a tool, that has been declared as haraam, for something that is legal...is also haraam.

Its just like saying, eating pork or drinking wine, for treating a persons illness.

[AnGeL_EyEs]

Re: What is your horoscope?

@mAd_ScIeNtIsT

There is no verse like that. There is a hadith that states that. And how can you be alone with someone when you are far apart from them???

helloooo ppl!! did the net exist back than? no it didnt…so how can their be a verse on this? their cant. ask any scholar or read the fatwas about the net …they will have answers…thats what fatwas are!