What is Imran's stance on Pak's creating and supporting Taliban against Afghan NA?

[Reverse_Swing]

Re: What is Imran’s stance on Pak’s creating and supporting Taliban against Afghan NA

@ravage

Wait a second. Lal Masjid != Drone Attack! I am asking about TTP. Every damn time TTP do a suicide bombing, Imran Khan talks about drone attacks. The perpetrators are usually known, Im asking if you have any evidence that they are typically, or in some sizable proportion drone attack affectees, as you claimed and as Imran Khan always claims.

How is a drone victim different from a Lal Masjid victim as far as their suffering is concerned? I just gave it as an example?

It isnt as if there is a lack of data. Yet why do you think Imran Khan, despite making this claim for several years, has not made available a study on the proportion of suicide bombers who were just angry young men forced to strike against a system that had let them down when they saw loved ones die through drone attacks and F-16s. If he has any such data, and he really should to be making this claim for so long, please reference it.

How can you take such an argument seriously? Im amazed that it is accepted at face value, just because its coming from a charismatic leader.

Where is the data? Besides who’s going to collect data from a war-torn area, a rugged terrain which is being shelled and bombarded almost on a daily basis. Perhaps the army even does not know every chuppa chuppa of FATA after 6 years of war.

Perhaps not enough emphasis? Why do you say that, on what basis. Is that more conjecture. Also, which are the moderate, non-violent elements within Taleban? There are surely Taleban we prefer, Taleban who are violent on the other side of the border. But its a stretch to call them moderate and its a stretch to call them non-violent.

Are you saying that everyone living in FATA = Taliban? Many in FATA get sucked into the extremist world view when all they see is darkness and carnage around them.

But lets say we did talk to the non-violent Taleban. That after all is the allegation against us. That we continue to keep a certain proportion of these snakes as pets. What do you think we should do with the violent Taleban? Specifically, TTP, Lashkar e Jhangvi,and other such organizations. What is the approach there

OK go & kill each and every one of them. Good Luck with that!