Re: What do Ahmedi’s call mainstream muslims?
Peace Mr.Popat
This is more sophistry from you … I asked a question - I did not make a statement … I said … that in your response to me about “how the claimants” were taken to be … instead of answering the question - you said “none of the claimants were ordered to be killed by RasoolAllah (SAW)” … that is when I asked “so you think that in order for someone to be deemed a liar then his death should be ordered” to which you are now accusing me of saying a liar has to be ordered to be killed" - no such thing … Again I am saying that the statement you made about “RasoolAllah (SAW) not ordering the killing of any one claimant” is a red-herring statement … The truth is … despite not ordering the killing of certain individuals it does not mean that they were not viewed as “false prophets” … Put it this way …
All of the claimants at the time of the our liege prophet Muhammad (SAW) NOT a SINGLE new claimant was ever believed to be TRUE … for this reason there is proof in the mindset of the Salaf that there is no chance for a NEW prophet to come. Rather each time they came instead of looking for signs of prophethood the companions (RA) used to check if those claimants showed signs of being the Dajjal.