Western standards regarding freedom of speech

Re: Western standards regarding freedom of speech

http://rt.com/news/222835-france-crackdown-hate-speech/

The arrest of a famous comedian and 54 more people for hate speech and pro-terror comments in the wake of the Charlie Hedbo attacks have sparked a fierce debate in France over whether the authorities are guilty of double standards on freedom of speech.

At the center of the debate is controversial comedian Dieudonne M’bala M’bala, known by his stage name Dieudonne, who was arrested after posting “I feel like Charlie Coulibaly” on Facebook, putting together the name of the attacked satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo and the terrorist who is accused of killing four people at a Jewish supermarket in Paris.

“Racism, anti-Semitism, historical revisionism, and condoning terrorism are not opinions, they are crimes,” French Prime Minister Manuel Valls said, condemning Dieudonne’s remark and vowing a crackdown on “speech that kills.”

The crackdown has 54 people, four minors among them, convicted for hate speech and inciting terror under special measures for immediate sentencing, introduced in the wake of the Charlie Hebdo attacks.

Inciting terrorism could mean a 5-year prison term in France, while the same offence committed online adds an extra two years to the sentence.

Dieudonne is set to face trial in February. Meanwhile a massive online campaign in his support is gearing up. The main message of those urging an end to his persecution is that it’s double standards to praise Charlie Hebdo’s activity, seen as provocative by many Muslims, and at the same time ban Dieudonne for his remarks.

Tweets condemning French authorities of violating freedom of speech have been accompanied by a #JeSuisDieudonné hashtag.

Maher Arar @ArarMaher](https://twitter.com/ArarMaher)
Follow
So France arrests Dieudonné 4 offending 70M French but praised publication of Hebdo even if offends 1.6B Muslims.

Moysekou™ @Moysekou](https://twitter.com/Moysekou)
Follow
" Freedom of speech in France seems to only be a right for those who want to speak out against Islam. #JeSuisDieudonne](https://twitter.com/hashtag/JeSuisDieudonne?src=hash)" @enrihannaaa](https://twitter.com/enrihannaaa)

A Facebook page in support of the controversial comedian features more than 900,000 “Likes.”
The comedian has already faced a number of charges of racism and anti-Semitism. He has defended his comments, using pretty similar free speech arguments to those used by Charlie Hebdo cartoonists.

You are looking for a pretext to forbid me,” he wrote in an open letter to French Interior Minister Bernard Cazeneuve. “You consider me like Amedy Coulibaly, when I am not any different from Charlie."

Re: Western standards regarding freedom of speech

How retarded has one to be to not recognize that insulting religious figures is same?

Re: Western standards regarding freedom of speech

Yes, I read that article a few days ago. And I agree there seems to be hypocrisy in certain European countries regarding freedom of speech. But in Scandinavia, Holocaust Denial is not outlawed. You can deny Holocaust to your heart's content. You will be condemned, you might get fired (just like expressing hatred against Muslims and immigrants can get you fired), but you can not be prosecuted in a court of law. There is no law which prohibits denial of holocaust.

About repercussion for expressing contrarian views. One incident I remember from the top of my head, which occurred in Sweden. A magazine called Ordfront published articles which held contrarian views on the Yugoslav Wars. Initially there was no reaction against it, but once the mainstream media picked up on these articles, Ordfront ended up firing several journalists and even their managing editor. They tried to conceal the reason behind these sackings, but eventually it caused an uproar, and Ordfront were sentenced to pay compensation to Mr Eklund, the managing editor who was sacked.

I am unable to google translate the article pertaining to it from swedish to english.
Obviously the views Mr Eklund and his journalists presented, were reprehensible.

Re: Western standards regarding freedom of speech

CNN anchor quits after row of tweets on Charlie Hebdo attack – The Express Tribune