[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by anjjan: *
AK, it is a wrong interpretation that Islam spared Hindus. The fact is that Islam could get expansion only in dark, uncivilized areas, after Arab societies to central Asia and in Africa. In India it faced a halt. In Spain, in a more advanced country Islam was totally out rooted.
The fact is that the civilized world has always rejected the notions of Islam.
For British tactics for an Israel, I think you are right. The British knew that only Jews could stand the Arabs in a nice way, and would not take double standard for religious hotchpotch.
[/QUOTE]
Well, Islam was not outrooted from Spain because of its weakness against Spanish civilization. Islam stayed in Spain for almost 700 years and finally Muslim emperors had to leave after a historic defeat in late 15th country. Now to say that Islam was outrooted from Spain because Spain was an advanced country and therefore, it rejected Islamic civilization is a mere distortion of history. I would like to present some facts to keep the record straight.
In fact, the period under discussion (5th century to 15th century) is known as Dark Ages in European history. One way of confirming my statement is by looking into any major history textbook that categorically describes the evolution of science, law, and politics. I challenge, that you will find a gap of almost 1000 years (if not more) between all of the major European inventions and scientific discoveries. For instance, lets talk about famous scientific discoveries. You will find the names of Greek scientists i.e. Archimedes (founder of famous Archimedes principle of Buoyancy), Pythagoras (a Greek philosopher and mathematician and founder of famous Pythagorean theorem of trigonometry). Following the Greek scientists would be scientists of 15h century i.e. Newton, Galileo etc. The same pattern can be observed when you will look into other subjects i.e. philosophy. A logical question comes into mind what happened in between ancient Greek times and 15th century? Well, that is the Dark Period in European history I was referring to. Nothing happened in whole Europe in terms of scientific, political and economic advancement with very few exceptions. And you are calling Spain and Europe of that Era a modern country?
Not that I am biased because of my Muslim background, but the fact remains that during those dark ages, the only civilization that was making advancements at every front was Muslim civilization. Muslims did a lot of work in mathematics, science and philosophy and I can cite tons of examples. Jabber Hayyan, Khawarzmi and Ghazali are just few names and if nothing else, one can do google search to learn about their caliber. Anyway that is the answer to Anjan’s comment when he called Spain a modern country and portrayed Islamic civilization of that time-period a backward civilization.
And to say that Islam did not make his way through Spain is absolutely wrong. Islam stayed there for 700 years and as a matter of fact, Muslim empire in Spain was one of the most glorious empires in whole Islamic world. Even today when you go to Spain you will find remnants of Arabic time-period. Not to mention Mosque Qurtaba, one of the most fascinating mosque is still present in Spain. So I have no idea where did Anjann find out that Islam could not made into Spain.
Now making a claim that Islam did not make into India….huh…I don’t know what to say about this……On a lighter note, if nothing else, the fact that this website is owned, maintained and managed by “Muslim Individuals” with all of them belonging to subcontinent clearly indicates that Islam made some impact on India….
On a serious note, I would like to clear that in my opinion, most of the wars between Muslims and Hindu rajas were fought for the extension of their respective kingdoms and not to preach and spread Islam. Warriors from both sides used religion for political reasons. So killings of millions of hindus in those wars has nothing to do with expansion of Islam. All of the Muslim warriors do not represent Islam. Babur, Mahmmod Ghaznavi did not come to India to spread islam. They had their own motives. So it is my request for my Indian friends to analyze stuff in its true perspective.
Islam in India was spread by Sufis and no one can deny that. The overwhelming presence of Hindus at Nazam-ud-Din Mazar at delhi and at Moeen-ud-Din-Chisthi’s mazar in Ajmeer Sharif even today is the clear proof of my claim. And I know my Indian friends know that very well…..