We Are All Collateral Damage

Apt article for today I think. Have a read folks.

*The Roads to Peace

The roads to peace are paths of war,
The gentle dove will leave her scar.
The moral men to say the least,
Will kill us all to get their peace.
The roads that lead to victories gained,
Are filled with people full of pain.
Only our Creator knew,
We’d kill so many to save so few.*

The recent terrorist tragedy in London is disheartening. Once again some nefarious force has seen fit to totally disregard innocent human life in pursuit of a vile agenda that few of us know and even fewer could understand. The response of the world leaders assembled in Edinburgh for the G-8 Summit is perhaps more disheartening, as it promises more of the misguided policies that have proven so ineffective in prosecuting the war on terror. The leaders of the Western powers continue to imply that they will fight violence with more violence of their own. If current events are any indicator of future developments, such a policy will only serve to beget yet more terrorism.

This is a war being guided on both sides by self-righteous murderers whose motives and proclamations mirror each other. Each side sees God as being exclusively with them. That being the case, the restraint and judiciousness urged by Christian and Islamic theology to guide the execution of war is cast aside with wanton impunity. Each side manipulates a vulnerable public to create a climate that allows for the perpetuation and the inevitable escalation of the ongoing slaughter. Each side reserves the right to use the spectacle of indiscriminate violence to “Shock and Awe” the opposition, yet will deny that its tactics can be described as terrorism. Each side sees their civilian population as hapless, innocent victims, while the suffering innocent civilians on the other side are acceptable collateral damage.

There will never be any real progress in ending this terror war, until we realize that we have all become collateral damage, unacceptable collateral damage. That being the case, there is no they or we in this affair. We are they and they are we. When a child in New York never sees his mother again because she was crushed in a collapsed tower at the World Trade Center, we all have suffered an irreplaceable loss. When an impoverished family in Afghanistan is bombed from the face of the Earth by a misguided missile, something of our collective humanity is destroyed by the blast. When a child in Iraq is born with gross birth defects due to his mother’s exposure to depleted uranium, we have all been deformed. When London commuters fear ever again entering the underground, because of the ill-advised actions of a handful of desperate fanatics, their insecurity touches us all.

We, the collaterally damaged, will continue to exist in a state of dehumanizing loss, deformity, and insecurity until we rise up, unite, and refuse to support at any level the policies of leaders who continually fail to heed one of the surest of all political lessons: killing innocent civilians will never lead to a positive outcome for the transgressing party. This realization is the first meaningful salvo anyone could fire in a real war on terror. However, as long as we are not as moved by the suffering of innocent civilians anywhere as we are by the suffering of those close to us, it will be a salvo that remains unfired.

Imam Zaid Shakir

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

A very thoughtful article. Thanks for sharing.

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

i absolutely agree.

good article mq :k:

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

MQ you should have posted the link to this article as well.

http://www.zaytuna.org/articleDetails.asp?articleID=76

Another ranting that pretty much muddles the debate and completely fails to blame the bombers of London tube system. Oh baba! These terrorists are running amok in the whole world.

If we ask this Maulvi about terrorist attacks on Shia Imam bargahs, what whould he say? Those poor Pakistani Shias are simply a collateral damage? What about the role of Sipah Suhaba terrorists? Are they simply attacking self-righteous Shia murderers?

Should we ask this Maulvi sahib that Taliban beat up poor women because these Burqa clad self-righteous murderers were threatening Tali-bobs?

This is simply a war lead by Waha-bibi criminals hell bent on destroying peace of the world. They think they can destroy their history and their present in Jannat-ul-Baqih, so now they have a free hand against Bamiyaan Budhas, Twin towers, London tubes, Karachi Imam Bargahs and you name it.

Off course this Maulvi Shakar sahib can go on writing these elaborate essays without realizing that trouble makers are from the mosques in the name of some Wahabi idol.

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

Antee dont start with me . Oh yeah thanks for the link my mistake for forgetting it. :rolleyes: .

If the article was to start blaming “the bombers of London tube system” it would clearly have to name and blame every single person, government and organization that let such hatred build up to such an extent in the first place. There are many terrorists in the world running about under various different banners.

The so called Maulvi is talking strictly about the London bombings and other such horrific crimes which are relevant. You wish to go off to burqa clad women, we’d have to go off to lala land to answer such a ridiculous comment with an equally ridiculous comment of our own.

And actually this is simply a war, filled with people who answer violence with violence. To find a solution to this issue, humans would have to rise above the pathetic- ness (introducing a new word) in which some seem to obviously exist at the moment.

(Apache and rav I’m glad somebody else found this article interesting seeing as how many different views are out there about the London attacks. )

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

Did you just forget to add your friends bombing your other beloved ones in Israel? you know, the ones who come from other places are backed by your other beloved non-wahabi country?

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

You’all wish it is a “war” by your favorite Talibani Tali-bobs. Unfortunately it is not. There were bunch of pathetics scurrying around with a kaboom in a back pack, or in a stolen car. This is no war, this is rather a “pathetic” situation where few eunichs hiding in caves, sleeping and eating in their own $hite, dreaming to be generals.

Wars are fought like men, with commanders, soldiers wearing their country’s flag, and a uniform.

Re: We Are All Collateral Damage

Hey didn't you say that people spread peace and not hate? What are you doing now?