was I right?

I was out shopping and saw money lying on the ground. I picked it up and gave it to customer service. This lady came up to me and said you could have put it in the donations to charity box.

What was the right thing to do? Its not my money but money lying on the ground is disrespectful to me. For me, handing the money to an authority like customer service was right. But, what should you actually do?

Re: was I right?

Well, how much money are we talking about?

Re: was I right?

Islamically, you should pick up that money only if

a. you know whose it is and
b. you are able to deliver it to them.

Re: was I right?

A 100 dhs note which is about 2000 pakistani rupees

Re: was I right?

I wonder if she'd have said that if it had been her money left on the floor lol

You did the right thing imo.. If no-one comes forward it can always be put in the charity box later..

Re: was I right?

You did the right thing, beats keeping it :p

Re: was I right?

That is exactly what I was thinking!

Re: was I right?

you were right. handing the money or the valuable to the customer service is the norm. the owner can ONLY call the customer service and often find their lost money or valuable. so, for the money or the valuable to be returned to the right owner, what you did was the right thing. however, if you found the money/valuable on the road, the better way would be to donate it anonymously on behalf of the owner whoever he/she may be.

Re: was I right?

I think you did the right thing. The owner of the money could drop by customer service later on. Hopefully the lady was just giving you the suggestion of giving it to charity and didn't intend to be rude. She can even choose to give it to charity herself if nobody comes to claim it. So, don't worry over it; it's really a non-issue.

Re: was I right?

I wouldn't have touched it. That way it wouldn't be my headache to return it to its owner.

Re: was I right?

You did the right thing.

Re: was I right?

you should have told the lady its none of her business. She didn't pick the money

Re: was I right?

I wud have done the same.