Was hz fatima(ra) correct when she demanded fadak as HER INTERITANCE?

[Mirch]

Re: Was hz fatima(ra) correct when she demanded fadak as HER INTERITANCE?

@psyah

Peace wellwisher4u

Why are you entertaining questions where you are making people regard the Sahaba as right or wrong? Astaghfirullah please have some decency and respect such topics are doing us no favours.

You are prodding the Shi’a members here for no reason. Just because others here are Sunni it does not mean that we automatically take the opposite position of classifying the Sahaba. We love them and do not fault them in any way. If you believed that your mother did wrong wellwisher4u would you come on a public forum and talk about it? For sure that is a shameful thing. Hz Fatimah (AS) is in the position of your mother, probably higher still.

This again will be a run on thread like your previous one … For sure you have better things to do than ‘debate’ - which is argumentation. Surely there are better ways to discuss. In the past the issue of fadak has already been addressed here, but it was brought up by Shi’a first we didn’t bring it up.

Jazzak Allah for your very sensible reply Psyah , I could not agree more. :k: