Voluntary and Involuntary Love

Randomly browsing through the Questions at www.islam.tc/ask-imam](http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam), I came across this outline of *voluntary and involuntary love, *subhanAllah, I think they are quite enlightening… The question itself maybe relevant or interesting to some too, so I’m pasting that too.

"I would like to know if it is haram to be in love with someone other than your spouse?

I was inlove with someone that I could not be married to because of our families. However, I am married now to someone else, yet I still feel love for the other person. I feel that I should be married to the one I love. I always think of that person even during intimate moments with my spouse and I feel I am being untruthful and unfare to this marriage. I have tried for the past two years (since I’ve been married) to forget about that person and move on. I understand that to be in love or fall in love with someone other than your spouse in baseless according to Islam. But what shall a person do when facing this dilema? How do I achieve control over my emotions? Please understand that I have no communication or contact with the one I’m inlove with. We have not spoken since before my wedding 2 years ago. Your detailed answer will be greatly appreciated and helpful! InshAllah…Aslamalakum

There are two types of love: voluntary and involuntary.

The involuntary love is where there is a feeling of love in the heart. But one does not cultivate or pursue this feeling. One tries to ignore this feeling but it causes pain. For this pain, one will be rewarded. The more one makes Sabr, uses one intellect and understands that it is not practical to follow the demands of this love, then one is drawing closer to Allah Ta’ ala due to the Sabr (patience) one is adopting.

The second type of love is voluntary. After experiencing the feeling of love in the heart, one contemplates about the beloved one. To have this type of love for someone besides one’s wife is sinful. It is sinful to intentionally fantasise about this other woman. If at the time of intimacy with one;s wife, one fantasises about this other woman, then you will be considered to be making Zina. You will get the sin of Zina because of your intentions while your wife will get no sin.

The solution is to ignore this love in the heart. Do not contemplate or
fantasise about this person and avoid contact with her. If any thought about this woman involuntarily enters the mind, ignore it. Ignoring it causes you pain then make Sabr, for which you will be highly rewarded. If you pass away in this state, then, Insha Allah, you will receive the reward of one who was martyred in the path of Allah Ta’ala.

Make Du’aa unto Allah Ta’ala to replace the love of a mortal with his
eternal love. May Allah Ta’ala grant us all his true love, Aameen.

and Allah Ta’ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai
FATWA DEPT. "

I’m going to ask-imam about the sources of these definitions, however accurate they seem to me, some of us still need to be reassured with sources :slight_smile: Also going to ask about involuntary love for someone before actually being married.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

I love Mufti Desai :D

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

Well...how does one fall "in love" w/o being married to the person? I think for real love to develop, you needt o talk to that person often, spend much time with them, etc.. the seeds for love to develop require alot of time with that person... i do not believe that u can jus t fall in love without knowing someone, because then ure in love with that IMAGE..

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

^ well, take it this way, the person was not a good muslim and had a girlfriend, later repented and became a good muslim....

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

You're definition of love may not be shared by everyone :) But I doubt that a conversation based on this would be very fruitful, simply because everybody has their own definition and understanding of how 'love' comes to exist in our hearts. It's not true to imply that all love before/outside marriage is illicit. It's not true to say that unless you've spent a great deal of time with a person, or unless its base is 'illicit', that it can't really be love at all :) This is not necessarily the case.

Allah (swt) places love and affection in our hearts, how and when is up to Him- it's our responsiblity what we do with that and our actions should reflect our choice. Love starts out pure, always. Let us not curse love if we ourselves corrupt it with our minds and actions, may Allah protect us all. It is not impossible for us to develop a love we may have, into love for the sake of Allah. And I think that is beautiful, subhanAllah.

wAllahu A'lam.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

so dil phenk ppl can get a lot of sawab when they move on without pursuing? yaaaaaaaay. who knew that i would get sawab for firgetting about that chica i fellin love with at the traffic light..but it turned green and I had to turn and she had to go straight.

sawab rocks.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

^ lol whether or not that is sarcy, I cant tell :p but yes, guard your actions and indeed, sawaab rocks.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love


I hope it's involuntary :D

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

A beautiful and to the point reply of Mufti Ebrahim Desai. May Allah bless him

JazakAllah khair for sharing.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

:smiley:

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

:lahol:

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

u might be joking, but if u accidentally saw some girl and ur heart was filled with ill desires, but u kept ur heart away fro such thoughts purely for seeking Allah’s pleasure, then u r indeed entitled for a huge sawab…

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

Mr. F, keep your eyes on the road. That way you won’t ‘accidently’ see any other humans you aren’t supposed to see (:maulana:) and it will probably help prevent accidents as well.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

^ I'm assuming your comment was not totally in jest as we don't want the quality and purpose of this thread to totally diminish now, do we :)

Doesn't judging other drivers (when 'meeting traffic' etc) also mean you have to look at their faces? eg. if someone is going to give you way, or doesnt look like they've seen you sort of thing? Lowering your gaze doesn't really work when you're driving...

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love


No, it doesn't. You sometimes have *to make eye contact when driving. If that other person driving happens to be a woman (this example obviously does not take place in Saudi Arabia), then you aren't *accidently seeing some girl. That was my point I was tyring to make through sarcasm. If you are lowering your gaze while driving it can easily cause an accident.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

ah, good old sarcasm :) sorry, ima bit slow :p

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

Semi sorry man I may become a typical suburban driver..eating, talking on the phone, changing radio station , figuring out what cd to play..all at the same time.

who has time to keep and eye on the road or on other ppl.

Re: Voluntary and Involuntary Love

May Allah reward Mufti Ebrahim Desai! Ameen.