various 'schools' of thought in Islam

[psyah]

Re: various ‘schools’ of thought in Islam

@vroom

Where-ever we have touched upon matters of fiqh, i recall you do not agree with deobandi/nadwi [for example Imam Abideen wahabi khawarij, Qasr Salah, beliefs] but anyway this is not important to me, something for you to think about.
And you have ditched them [deobandis] on beliefs too
So I have nothing to say about these frivolous [non] points, I will say there is Markers that define us and our religion. I know some of these markers.
if avoiding fanaticism means you are neutral then neutralism on those points is what you are upon. It may be that i take an opinion on neutralism

Thank you, it can be said talib ur rehman has benefited more from us then you

Peace brother vroom

Yes again some of these are the case … I also agree that Barelvis are orthodox, but I also state that they specifically gathered momentum as a reactionary group to Deobandis and that is why Sh Ahmad Raza Khan (RA) is credited for being the founder … Just see the mark in historical timeline to get my point.

I am not neutral in view … The accusation that Deobandis are Wahabis needs to be cleared. There is no connection the sets of scholars are very different … Only certain concepts are shared by accident between them … Historically they started in a similar time quite independently from one another in different locations.

I would like the Deobandi ulema to remove some of the concepts they have in their books … For example … The suggestion that Allah (SWT) can lie … This idea is not from the Salaf.

In terms of what I understand about avoiding fanaticism … It is my belief to be a certain way … However not to hold others in contempt for not being that way as they might have their reasons for their beliefs … And they may be in a transition to guidance and my judgementalism may be the cause of sending them away from my position. So I would sooner say something is erroneous than call someone a kafir or outside of Ahl-us-Sunnah wal-Jamaa’.

By the way I believe Sh. Asrar Rashid is friends with Sh. Yaseen … Who is a senior mureed of my Shaykh, I believe I have met Sh. Rashid in person a few times.