US massacres civilians in Fallujah

The Pentagon does not bother to count its victims and has imposed a regime of strict censorship, abetted by the self-enforcement of the corporate media. However, from the few reports coming out of the besieged city, it is absolutely clear that the basic purpose of the US campaign is to reduce it to rubble, killing and terrorizing as many inhabitants as possible.

Residential buildings, hospitals and mosques have all been bombed, and American troops are engaging in a house-to-house search of whatever remains. Tens of thousands of civilians remain in Fallujah, a medium-sized city near Baghdad that is normally home to 300,000 people.

A New York Times reporter “embedded” with US troops described the onslaught: “Just before the marines began to push south into Falluja, the American bombardment intensified, and heavy artillery could be heard pounding positions in or near the city every few minutes. An entire apartment complex was ground to rubble. A train station was obliterated in a hail of 2,000-pound bombs. All electrical power in the city was cut off about 5 p.m.”

The account passes over without comment the destruction of an apartment complex and train station—both civilian structures.

**US planes bombed a government health clinic that had been treating wounded insurgents and civilians in the center of Fallujah, killing both patients and staff.

Bakr al-Dulaimi told Al Jazeera that the bombings targeted everything in the city including the hospital, houses and cars. “Al Dulaimi said the hospital’s staff, doctors and patients have all fallen victim to the assault.” **

“Residents said smoke was rising from the whole city as it shook to constant explosions. Civilians were huddled in their homes and there was no word on casualties…An AFP [Agence France-Presse] reporter in Jolan [a district of Fallujah] said one building in every 10 had been flattened. As US-led troops closed in on the neighborhood overnight, at least four 2,000 pound (900-kilogram) bombs were dropped on the city’s northwest.”

“My son got shrapnel in his stomach when our house was hit at dawn, but we couldn’t take him for treatment,” said Abbud, a schoolteacher. “We buried him in the garden because it was too dangerous to go out.”

On Monday, the US took control of Fallujah’s main hospital outside the city center in order to prevent doctors there from reporting on the level of civilian casualties. Sami al-Jumaili, a doctor at the hospital who managed to escape arrest by American troops, told Reuters that there were very few medical supplies and clinics open to treat the injured.

Patients in the hospital were handcuffed and dragged out of their rooms for examination by troops. The US puppet, Prime Minister Allawi, has reportedly said that forces entering the hospital had “captured four foreigners and killed 38 persons.”

No one is being permitted to leave the city as the US military carries out the slaughter. A ring of US and British soldiers has been set up around the city. US Colonel Michael Formica told the Associated Press that this was necessary to prevent any insurgents from escaping dressed in civilian clothing.

“My concern now is only one: not to allow the enemy to escape,” he said. “I do not want these guys to get out of here. I want them killed or captured as they flee.”

The US actions in Fallujah are not only a moral outrage, they are a direct violation of international law, which prohibits indiscriminate attacks on civilian centers. According to Additional Protocol 1 of the 1949 Geneva Conventions, “Parties to the conflict shall at all times distinguish between the civilian population and combatants and between civilian objects and military objectives and accordingly shall direct their operations only against military objectives.”

The Geneva Conventions were adopted in the aftermath of the atrocities committed by the Nazis in occupied Europe, wholesale attacks on civilian populations like the razing of the Warsaw Ghetto and the wiping out of the Czech village of Lidice. Now Washington is reviving the very methods that the world formally repudiated 55 years ago.

Washington’s pretense—dutifully parroted by the US media—that these actions are being taken to ensure democracy and allow for peaceful elections in January is an absurdity.

These actions are being carried out in the face of enormous opposition from the vast majority of the Iraqi population, an opposition that the attack on Fallujah will only intensify.

According to media reports, upwards of 500 of the Iraqi troops—out of a total of 2,000 mobilized for the operation—disappeared before it began. A senior officer in the Iraqi police abandoned his post after learning of the plans for the invasion of Fallujah, presumably in order to inform the resistance.

The Association of Muslim Scholars, a group of leading Sunni clerics, denounced the invasion, appealing to “all those who live with a conscience around the world” to oppose the “massacres and elimination war” in Fallujah. The group called for a boycott of the January elections, saying that any such elections would be held “over the corpses of those killed in Fallujah and the blood of the wounded.”
US massacres civilians in Fallujah

**The masscre of civillians by the amerikkkan terrorist pigs and the stooge allawi will not be forgotten. This is a complete sham the Geneva convention and Human rights that these hypocritical Westerners harp on about is nothing but fancy words in reality because on the ground the amerikkans are nothing but brainless thugs who will get what they deserve when they are booted out of iraq because they have started fires across the whole country!

The hypocrites from the west who say we liberating the iraqis from saddam have no leg to stand on because they are even more sadistic and sick in the head than saddam hussien ever was!

If this is what treatment the amerikkans give to iraqis no wonder they enjoy living under the dictator saddam hussien even more!**

This events in Falluja is another War Crime i have been watching the American news media from an unbiased position and it is a total white wash what they are showing democracy and establishing rule of law is a sham!

History will show the American Government in thier true light this whole Iraq incident has been illegal since day 1.

But the most condemnation should not be directed at america it should be directed at those impotent regimes in the middle east who must be watching there fellow brothers slaughtered daily and doing nothing about it!

Ah, the respected "World Socialist" web site. I wonder if they wrote this article before or after the assault actually began.....

Ohio please don't patronize people you know aswell as everyone else there are war crimes being committed in Fallujah if your going to deny this obvious fact with 2000lb bombs landing on peoples homes then you are fooling no one but yourself.

2000 lb bombs do not make a war crime. Brush on your law of land warfare and make a presentation. Other than AlJazeera, who has had the same story on it's web site for three days, there is no credible evidence that a huge number of civilians have been hurt.

Now take into account that the US had a massive leaflet campaign warning people to evacuate, and that a huge portion of the population is encamped in Red Crescent tents outside the town, and you would have to think that the remaining civilians are either sympathizers, or stupid.

The insurgents won the conflict in April through public pressure during a US election year. The same tactic cannot work this time, even though they are trying to whip gullible muslims into a frenzy. I see you fell for it!

2000lbs bombs+ Air Strikes, Helicopter gunships, tank fire, missles targetting mosques, hospitals, houses, apartments, and schools are not war crimes are you for real.

Absolutely.

First, just because weapons are powerful does not mean they are illegal. Second, when fighters occupy Mosques, schools and houses, they lose their prospected status. It is the fighters who first occupy these locations that commit the violation. If US troops are shot at from a mosque, they can retaliate.

Stop you whining. Either present specific facts, or plug it. Just because you do not like war, especially where the US is massively overpowering, does not mean it is a "war crime". And frankly alleging wr crimes has become so frequent and lame that it threatens to devalue "real" war crimes.

Every unit has a lawyer embedded to "vet" targets. They literally have veto power over the field commanders decsions to strike with bombs and other heavy weapons. Do some research and you will find this true.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ohioguy: *
Ah, the respected "World Socialist" web site. I wonder if they wrote this article before or after the assault actually began.....
[/QUOTE]

funny u just missed the thread about shooting of unarmed wounded iraqi....now thats a war crime...

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ohioguy: *
2000 lb bombs do not make a war crime. Brush on your law of land warfare and make a presentation.
Now take into account that the US had a massive leaflet campaign warning people to evacuate, and that a huge portion of the population is encamped in Red Crescent tents outside the town, and you would have to think that the remaining civilians are either sympathizers, or stupid.

The insurgents won the conflict in April through public pressure during a US election year. The same tactic cannot work this time, even though they are trying to whip gullible muslims into a frenzy. I see you fell for it!
[/QUOTE]

OG is absolutely right. If your country is taken over, you either have the choice to fight, flee or accept defeat. Instead of going in and taking over a populated city, US had a massive campaign to get the "flee and accept defeat" portion of the population out. The "fight" part of the population deserve respect for their bravery to stick around, but it's no war crime to fight those who want to fight you. Its called war for a reason.

Whether the invasion was right or wrong, a war took place and a country was taken over. The Iraqi government decided that instead of pitting its army against the U.S. army, it would fight a guerilla war (knowing full well that this would cause greater civilian casualties). It is the Iraqi leaders who are to blame. Instead of accepting defeat or fighting with an army, they decided to fight a guerilla war, fully willing to accept countless deaths of civilians. The insurgents just want to fight whether it is in a mosque or a civilian neighborhood and shift all the burden of protecting their own civilians to a foreign invading army! It seems to me that the foreign invading army cares more about the safety of Iraqi civilians than the Iraqi insurgents.

That probably is a war crime.

Dropping bombs is not in and of itself a war crime.

Funny EVERYONE here is ignoring the body of the Western woman whose face was so disfigured she cannot be identified, and is missing all of her arms and legs. Do you think the butcher who dismembered her just had some battle shock and cut off her limbs in the "heat of the moment"?

^ was she a civilian of fallujah? I dont think so, hence its irrelevent in this thread.

^^Her body was found in Fallujah.

Here we go again!

The bloodthirsty amerikkkan terrorist pigs kill thousands of iraqis in Fallujah then claiming no civillians died and its not war crime!

These Amerikkkan right wingers i don’t know how they got the nerve to come on here everytime with all their bulls%^& claiming they spreading democracy and humanity is killing thousands of people humanity!

:konfused:

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ohioguy: *
^^Her body was found in Fallujah.
[/QUOTE]

That might be a war crime, but we haven't seen any evidence yet. Just because he chopped her limbs off, doesnt mean its a war crime.

And just because mice don't live on the moon doesn't mean it isn't made of cheese!

People chatting about 1 woman my goodness thousands of iraqis have been killed in fallujah! :mad2:

^ thats what i was saying, this one woman is rather irrelevant at the moment.

seminole: stop being a cheesy git. sarcasm flew over your head i think.

"claiming no civillians died and its not war crime!"

Oh no, civilians died. They shouldn't have. They should have evacuated. Next you will say, "Why should they evacuate, it's their home.". Because common sense says that when a big military conflict comes to your town, you either get out or die. The "thousands of Iraqis who died" were mostly bad people. Screw em'.

The "one woman" may well have been a woman who spent thirty years of her life working for an aid organization helping Iraqi's. She counts.

War is brutal folks. Get used to it, it's gonna go on a long time.

^ lol too funny. Did bush hire you or someting?

When we get the final tally of civilians killed in Fallujah, let's make sure that we distinguish between the civilians used as human shields by the insurgents and then executed by them when they fled advancing troops. Let's also distinguish between the ones who were shot by insurgent snipers as they tried to flee to safe houses and encampments set up by the US forces. Let's also distinguish between the ones who did perish by a US bullet while the insurgent thugs forced them to act as protective sand bags.