Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Australia’s Simon Taufel and England’s Ian Gould will be the on-field umpires for the high-voltage World Cup semifinal between India and Pakistan in Mohali on Wednesday. New Zealand’s Billy Bowden will be the third umpire and Australian Rod Tucker the fourth umpire.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/Taufel-Gould-to-officiate-in-India-Pakistan-semis/Article1-678240.aspx

This is the same pair which officiated in Champion Trophy semifinal between Pakistan vs New Zealand and several decisions went against Pakistan. Later Taufel apologized to Umar Akmal for giving him out.

Now Ian Gould is quite a poor umpire having given horrible decisions in the past, many of these against Pakistan.

It will be important for Afridi to use the referrals wisely which he often does not.

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

I wish they had Billy Bowden on the ground :bummer:

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Is this based on their bias against south asian countries in general when they play Eng, SA, Aus, NZ, or is this specific to bias against Pak?

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Being Pakistani fan i can only speak for Pakistan because its Pakistans matches that i have seen. But i think even SL and India have complained about poor decisions by Ian Gould. Bangladesh were also at receiving end of poor decisons against England by aussie and kiwi umpires.

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Aussie umpires are always biased against Asians!

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

IMO, the bias will be balance out in this game.

Question is - why are western umpires still dominant in international cricket? Ditto coaches.

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

^They are more biased against Pakistan.

Frankly Asian coaches have not taken up the challenges. They should start by taking up smaller teams and work their way upwards. As for the umpires, i think asian boards are lax when it comes to dealing with white umpires. Asoka was quickly sidelined for his poor decisions and yet Daryl has not been.

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Exactly my thoughts ..... harper is half blind yet on Asoka was removed ..... and to be honest Harper has History of poor decisions ..... the DRS only highlighted it but yet ICC isn't giving it a thought ..... just watch a few matches invloving Harper and Asian teams (especially Pakistan) and u'll notice what a big blunder this guy is

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

No Aleem Dar for the 2nd Semi :bummer:

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

In addition to Asian board being lax, the western commentators are tougher when Asian umpires make mistakes - they beat it to death. While they look the other way for the most part when mistakes are made by western umpires. Exceptions are ther of course - this is my observation based on limited viewing of various matches.

Re: Umpires Announced For Semifinals

Today is the last chance for people to see world's best umpire Aleem Dar in action in this WC.