UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

London: An Indian-origin mother, who beat her 7-year-old son to death for failing to memorise the Quran, was on Monday sentenced to life for killing him and setting his body on fire to hide evidence after applying barbeque gel.

A sobbing Sara Ege, 33, collapsed and had to be helped from the dock after being told that she would serve 17 years before she could be considered for parole.

Cardiff crown court heard that Sara, a mathematics graduate from India, treated her son Yaseen “like a dog” when he struggled to memorise passages of the holy book of Islam. She beat him on the hands and his body until he collapsed on the floor of his bedroom and died in July 2010, the Guardian reported

She was also found guilty of perverting the course of justice and given a four-year sentence for that crime, the BBC reported.

Her husband Yousuf Ege, a taxi driver, was cleared of allowing the death of a child by failing to protect him. Sara had pleaded not guilty to murder and claimed her husband was responsible for Yaseen’s death.

While sentencing her, Justice Wyn Williams said: “I am satisfied that it was his failure to learn the Koran that day that resulted in the beating that caused his death”.

"On the day of Yaseen’s death you had kept him home from school so he could devote himself to his study of the Koran.

"He was memorising passages but on that day Yaseen must have failed in some way and it was that which was a trigger for the beating. You killed your own son. At the time of the killing he was particularly vulnerable because of his age and because of his relative physical frailty.

“In killing your son you abused a precious relationship of trust which does and should exist between a parent and a child,” the judge said.

“This prolonged cruelty culminated on the day of his death in what was a savage attack. You then set fire to his body in an attempt to evade responsibility for what you had done”.

It was initially thought Yaseen had died in a fire, but tests later revealed he had died hours earlier. But a postmortem examination revealed he had died before the fire had begun and had suffered multiple injuries to his body caused by three months of physical punishment.

The jury was told that Sara and her husband, enrolled Yaseen in advanced classes at a local mosque because they wanted him to become Hafiz someone who memorises the Quran.

As a child, Sara had herself committed large sections of the book to memory and entered competitions to demonstrate her ability. But she became increasingly frustrated when her son was unable to do as well as she expected and began beating him, the court was told.

Sara said she frequently promised herself that she would stop attacking her son but could not resist beating him. She claimed she had been urged on by the devil and bad spirits. At one point she believed the stick she used to punish her son was possessed by an evil spirit.

In a complicated series of claims and counter-claims Sara had confessed to the murder and then retracted that confession, the BBC reported.

She claimed her husband and his family forced her to make the confession and that he was the killer. The harrowing confession was recorded by police and shown to the trial jury in evidence.

In it, Sara described how Yaseen collapsed after she had beaten him while still murmuring extracts of the Koran. She then used barbeque gel to burn her son’s body in an attempt to hide the evidence.

“I was getting very wild and I hit Yaseen with a stick on his back like a dog.” She later retracted her statement.

UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran - World - IBNLive

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

Good! (that she was jailed), minimum of 17 years is crap. Should be at least 25.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

sick sick sick

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

If this is true…then …absolutely shocking and terribly sad to say the least.
Yet another incident which shows that we Muslims do pray, go to Hajj, give Zakat…etc. but do not have any Akhlaq.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

god :smack: another story that so helps the “muslim image” :hinna:

she thought she was a wonderful muslim so wonderful that she wanted her sn to memorize the quran… she killed her son for failing in that seems like she learned absolutely nothing from that quran

17 years kam hain she should get life im sorry

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

The surprising bit is her being a Math grad. The education did her no good.
And where does Islam say that it’s okay to beat your kid to death? The woman clearly lacked restraint.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

But it does say you can beat them for something as simple as not praying.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

SHE collapsed SOBBING for getting 17yrs? stupid woman, killing her own child..she should’ve collapsed dying!

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

Yeah. But then people discipline their kids for all kinds of things. Not doing their homework or chores.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

@ beeb

I don’t blame you for having a point of view because that is your right, I respect that fully. But after seeing how you scrutinize the Quran i am not surprised by whatever you have to say about Islam or Muslims.
I don’t agree with it but we all have our opinions so you are entitled to have yours.

Again I dont understand why “religion” has to be such an issue everything a Muslim(a) is involved in something bad…So far i did not see any Muslim NOT denouncing what the mother did.
And thats the main thing, that we all in once voice condemn her action.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

[note]Please keep discussion to the topic. I will create a new topic for you guys to discuss Hoodbhoy. I’m gonna move the posts from here to there. [/note]

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

This is pathetic. She should be given a life sentence.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

probably cookoo in the head.

if not for memorising quran, she might have beaten the kid to death over some other minor thing.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

One thing I don’t understand, why is there such a huge emphasis on memorizing the Holy Qur’an?

Don’t get me wrong, the people who go about it the right way, m’A, that’s great. But from what I’ve seen, people just want their children to memorize Surahs, but are they being taught the translation of the Surahs? Or the lessons behind them?

Either way, this is really sad.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

We will do our best not to “get you wrong” lolz (just kidding).
nothing wrong or unusual about emphasis on memorizing the Holy Quran because its the way of life for Muslims.
Its as important as getting a degree or graduating at a university if not more important.

The paradox is that in our culture we (here i am only talking about Pakistan) tend to send those children to Madrassas or Hifz e Quran schools who have failed in regular schoold.
I know that not all the children who are not good learners are sent to religions schools but alot of them are send because they were not good in learning at a regular school.

Another problem is the way they teach at Madrassas or Hifz e Quran schools. There is a very tough regime there (I think its not as tough in UK) and the teachers are very strict. That
should not be allowed and children should be given choice to memorize the Quran and to have religious education. Best is when it goes hand in hand.
One should teach the children about religion and worldly life. But life most things that fail in life…where there is no balance things go wrong there.

Anyhow i think i am now even confusing myself lolz so i stop.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

That’s a whole other can of worms…:halo:

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

Without making this religion specific, this is the case with say Vishnu Sahasranamam. We were made to chant this every evening. Took 45 min. Add other bhajans and 1.5 h. Were not taught meaning. Not a good way to get kids interested.

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

What a sick woman!!! Poor little boy .. :frowning:

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

Its parents like that force their kids to drink and smoke weed and all sort of ungodly things becuase they force religion on the kids and the kids then naturally rebell against it. Such a wrong way to teach such a beautiful religion.

Stupid woman, how can she even think that a 7 year child could understand the Quran at his age? The Quran in itself is a life long learning process, you can’t just memorize it and then pretend that you have earned heaven.

As the Quran says “Indeed they have incurred the wrath of Allah.”

Re: UK: Indian-origin woman gets life for killing son for not memorising Quran!

Sounds like a mentally ill woman. The urges to be violent that she talks about and how she was paranoid about ghosts/evil spirits etc are a clear indication of her being a psycho. I’ve heard this in almost every crime documentary that I’ve watched (and I’ve watched hundreds) how psychos get this urge to be violent, they just can’t help it. Heck even rapists and murderers usually have a soft spot in their heart for their kids if no one else but this woman was just beyond sick. This is completely abnormal behaviour for a mother, another indication of a psychopath because she lacks empathy even for her own child and flips out in such a frightening way over something so minor.

Poor baby. :frowning: