Two things that can't co-exist in the same place:

Music and remembrance (zikr) of Allah (s.w.t)

When I am ironing my clothes, polishing my shoes, working out in the Gym, or driving…etc. either I am singing or listening to any song to keep myself excited or my tongue is experiencing the sweetness of Darood sharif, kalma…etc. which warms my heart with feelings of purity.

BUT which one should I prefer to keep myself motivated ? Allah mentions this quality of a “Mo’min” in the Quran that their tongues are always fresh with the “Zikr” recitations of Allah either they are siting, standing or lying on soft beds.

BUT what benefit or harm do I get when I continue to do any of these activities in my life ?

One quality of zikr is that it removes the hurdles (troubles) from my way which are waiting for me (written in my fate) in the near future, but the greater benefit is that it makes zikr my strong habit.

What is the benefit of a strong habit ? Well, when one is totally confused and fearful one unintentionally performs one’s strong habit as the mind is not working properly. like after knowing that there is an earthquake, due to intense fear I might unintentionally run towards the room which I visit most often. SO ?

So, when I see the angel of death at the time of death I would be so scared and fearful that unintentionally I would be following my biggest habit.

Either I would be able to achieve what is mentioned in the hadith " the person who is able to recite Kalma-e-Tayyab at the time of death would directly go to Jannah"

OTHERWISE, there are a lot of other cases. A person singing his favorite song, another counting money, another business talking,…etc. while people around them failed to understand why at the last moments the person is not reciting

“LA ILAHA ILLALLAHU MOHAMMADUR RASUL ALLAH”

May Allah bless us with the strength and wisdom to decide now, what we want to make our best habit before it is too late…

Re: Two things that can't co-exist in the same place:

Or you can combine both to form Quwali...

The spirit of Quwali is the lyrics and the mUsic is just to string together the heart...

Re: Two things that can't co-exist in the same place:

Nice reminder R.A.W. Afterall there are no benefits whatsoever in listening music or singing. However, whilst doing work, if we engage ourselves in the Zikr of Allah, we have positive effects multiple iA! When doing any work like any household chore, if i am humming to any song that got stuck in my head, I try to, in the least when i remember, focus on doing Zikr. It's true that music and zikr cannot co-exist.

Also, if the Quranic recitation is on the TV and if you are listening to music in the room (and you can hear the TV)...would you still continue listening to music then or would you switch it off?

I read this on the net "
Ibn Maajah
It is reported from Abdullah ibn Mas'ood (May Allah be pleased with him):
"Music sows hypocrisy in the heart like water causes seeds to grow in soil."
Ad-Durru al-Manthoor
*
Allah says in the Qur'an:
*"And when they (the believers) hear what is futile they turn away from it, and they say, Unto us our deeds; and unto you your deeds. Peace be upon you. We do not follow the ignorant ones." [Qur'an Al-Qasas 28:55]

Re: Two things that can’t co-exist in the same place:

R A W and B A :k: