To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

A very good article. It goes to show Pakistan needs Musharaf more than ever. It is not in Pakistan’s neighbors and other countries interest to see a destabilized Pakistan.

Despite many challenges, to its credit, USA has not backed away from its promise of continued support to Pakistan, which many believed would only last a couple of years.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2008/01/04/EDJ3U8686.DTL

To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy

Pakistan’s political crisis, triggered by the assassination of Benazir Bhutto and the ensuing violence sweeping the country, is a worrisome development in South Asia and beyond. Without a doubt, Pakistan’s political decay will affect its neighbors, including Afghanistan, just as Pakistan itself for decades has been impacted by conflict spilling over from beyond its (contested) borders.
Indeed, a good deal of Pakistan’s turmoil can be traced to the regional sources of instability that have acted as the breeding ground for the military government that has shaped Pakistan since the country’s independence in 1947.

From the Indo-Pakistan conflict, which has led to a nuclear arms race, to the internationalized conflict in Afghanistan, to the armed uprising in the disputed territory of Kashmir, Pakistan is today ensconced in a fragile political environment that will likely remain that way for a generation. This unstable political situation will be compounded by numerous internal conflicts, such as ethnic separatism in Baluchistan and Sindh provinces and the recent uprising in the Federally Administrated Tribal Area (FATA) bordering Afghanistan, each of them requiring a distinct political solution.

With Bhutto’s assassination, it will be more difficult for Pakistan to transition to a democratic government. More modest domestic political gains from its elections, now postponed until February, should be expected. Certainly, Pakistan’s future hinges on whether control of the country will remain with the army or transition back to a civilian government.

Pakistani leader Gen. Pervez Musharraf is here to stay and the United States now needs to rethink its policy toward Pakistan. A clue to his staying power is his pragmatic and delicate handling of foreign policy, particularly with respect to the strategic development of the U.S.-India nuclear pact, widely interpreted in Pakistan as the United States’ intention to insure that Pakistan’s arch-enemy, India, is the leading power in South Asia.

**Under Musharraf, Pakistan has steered an independent foreign policy while maintaining an alliance with the United States, by strengthening ties with Russia, China, Iran and other regional players weary of the “American agenda.” Case in point: The United States has not welcomed any warming of tied between Iran and Pakistan, and Musharraf has defied the United States’ call to shelve the Iran-Pakistan-India pipeline, a proposed $7 billion pipeline to deliver natural gas from Iran to India and Pakistan. **

Bhutto went out of her way to show herself aligned with Bush’s war on terrorism. Bhutto never criticized U.S. policy that seemed to elevate India in the region, thus many in the Pakistani military elite saw her in a negative light.

So now, how does the United States harmonize regional security imperatives with democratic politics in Pakistan? Should these imperatives be recast in favor of a new Pakistan policy that takes into consideration Pakistan’s national security worries, which only partially coincide with those of the United States and thus limit full democratization of Pakistan?

**Hectoring Pakistan’s civil-military elite about democracy has clearly backfired. Bhutto’s assassination has tipped the scales in favor of the ruling politico-military elite focused on national (security) interests. The latter’s overriding concern now is to have some breathing space domestically. **

It would be a major U.S. foreign policy blunder to indulge Musharraf in bashing Bhutto’s internal detractors. The United States needs to seriously consider recasting its India policy in favor of a more balanced approach, while steering clear of Pakistan’s domestic politics. Otherwise, the United States risks further alienation of Pakistan’s political elite.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Read the article in the economist, the one thats got more WEIGHT and IMPORTANCE

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

It is Mush that has destabilised Pakistan, and torn at the federation like no leader before. Never in my life have I seen Pakistan as gloomy as it is today.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Can you deny the anti pakistani chants at BB's funeral? Just goes to show who wants to destroy the federation. Nuff said.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Aalsi, I bet you literally fell over yourself to get this posted… :smiley:

I can just picture you googling the term “Musharaf the greatest leader in history” to find this article… :hehe:

To bad for you, but just about EVERYONE recognizes that Mush is a liability and will end up destroying Pakistan if he sticks around.

Regardless of what India does, its Mush who is responsible for destroying the internal environment of the country with or without American meddling.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

He thinks that hes still popular amongst the ppl as he stated. This just shows that hes either senile, or a shameless liar.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Were you surprised to hear the Anti Pak chants when someone like Musharaf is in power? While Mush has ruled the roost, resentement in the smaller provinces has grown like never before. You cant blame anyone but your beloved dictator for that.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Its typical of all dictators.. They surround themselves with so many chamchas that they lose sight of reality...

You can just imagine the Chaudrys reassuring Mush that he is still beloved across the country, and Mush goes on with bussines as usual completely oblivious of the fact that he's despised..

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Well lets look at it this way, all the economic development done by Shaukat Aziz is credited to Mush because he was the leader of the country than all the upheaval and the lawlessness and growth in terrorism has also to be credited to him because ALL of it happened during his time in office and due to his inept and incompetent handling.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

He does'nt have to think he is popular. He dictates remember?
Not sure if he is senile or liar, but one thing for sure. He is the one that Mullah hate the most. enough said.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Lawyers, Media, Civilians, Politicians, Mollahs, eveyrone hates him the most Jack.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

^^ how about vanished all of them?

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Aalsi, you gotta be Musharraf himself to come up with such things and the arguments to prove how much we need you. Its lame, lammer and lamest as your tenure closes to end.

Its called 'uzre gunnah badtar uz gunnah'. 8 years were not enough to allign our foreign policy and stopping internal ideological crises. So much for 'sub se pehle Pakistan' and 'enlightened moderation' ideologies.

More back tracking and blame game to expect from GHQ/President House. Looks like the 40 days delay might become 4 years like Zia's promise soon.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

I am surprised to hear anti-Pakistan chants from Pakistanis. I can understand anti-government chants as people can voice their opinions about the govt. But anti-Pakistan chants is a no no from people that call themselves Pakistanis.

I am surprised PPP supporters chanting anti-Pakistan slogans again after what happened in 1971 and the role played by their leader in the break-up of Pakistan.

Once again it shows PPP hypocracy of saying they want to keep Pakistan together after their anti-Pakistan chants over the past few days. Tsk, tsk, tsk.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

LOL, your proaganda isn’t working.

The PPP is what is holding back the wave of seperatist feeling in the country, and keeping the federation together

http://thenews.jang.com.pk/top_story…l.asp?Id=11984

Zardari perhaps never in his life looked as mature as he sounded on Sunday while denouncing those who had been raising anti-Pakistan slogans in Garhi Khuda Bux during the last few days.** He said thrice in Sindhi language “we want Pakistan”, “we want Pakistan”, “we want Pakistan”** to respond to some anti Pakistan slogans raised by a section of the mourners of Benazir Bhutto.

Zardari also came out well while intentionally repeating his party’s commitment to remain a national party and continue to be a symbol of the unity of the federation. He said the PPP had been and would remain an advocate of a strong federation.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

then who will be left to live in pak? it would be just a small harem of mushtards and mushy himself.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Pakistan is the Pakistani people. If people don’t feel the state represents them any more…then…they dont cheer for the state :AID:

They get :mad: and :grumpy: and :nook: instead of :biggthumb. And need be take up :shikari: and say :peshow:

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

Not supporting Mush doesnt mean you dont support Pak... I think the greatest thing anyone can do for PAK if they consider themselves a Pakistani, and a HUMAN BEING, who cares for people, is turn their backs on this dictator...

PPP supporters woudlnt be chanting anti Pak slogans if Mush would have done something to improve the nations cohesion.. Instead he has polarized it and thing are as bad as ever.

1971 is all open to debate.. Lets not forget the wonderful leadership of then dictator Yaya Khan... And lets not forget what led to the crisis of 1971... The great leadership of Ayub Khan...
Dictatorship and military rule you see have done some grave harm to the country, just like this dictators. You need to read some history buddy;)

PPP isnt responsible for the break up of the country, it misrule, lack of democracy, and dictatorship that destroyed the country... You can truly lay many of Paks problems at the feet of her dictators and the Army...

Most of the problems that occured are because there is not Demcoracy... The Army has taken some decisions on its own, unilateraly and that has resulted in the mess we are intoday...

The problem is that civilian politicians usually end up cleaning the mess left by the previous dictator, and then people like you come down on them for not doing a good job...

So learn some history. It not the fault of civilian politicians that the Army has undermined every institution and destroyed any prospects of a succesful civilian democratic govt.

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

LOL.. The kitten is wonderful. I wonder where all these Mush supporters will be when he is gone?!?! Will they still be here singing his praises or hide someplace from shame?

Re: To stabilize Pakistan, U.S. needs to rethink India policy.

:rotfl: Well they are our countrymen. At one time we were in the minority in this forum too. They’ll come around. If not, then..well…uh… I mean look at this: :phajja: :k337: