some mazedar and thoughtfull cartoons on "Amr bil munkar - Ordering what’s bad
I am not sure what you are trying to say here zero1. Do you believe that you can invoke name of Muhammad:saw: while praying? Do you not believe that Allah can hear you? Is it necessary to say Ya Muhammad:saw:. I am sorry, I missed the point of the cartoons.
It is one thing to ask people to follow Islam, it is quite another to teach them what Islam is. You only pray to Allah…Quran is very clear about it.
Actually Zero 1 didn't like something on another thread.
So he is disturbed now which is clear from his threads.
/\ LOL,
the thread was meant to be for both shia and sunnis, if you dont like it or not belong to both groups then why bother replying it. simply stay away. ;)
isn’t this the same cartoonist sect that reportedly encouraged people to display a picture of Prophet Muhammad (saw)??..
^ i dunno, but i dont think one person actually makes up a whole sect.
Kaleem: some people ask Allah (swt), to answer thier prayers, by invoking the names of the ahlul bayt, or ask the ahlul bayt to plead to Allah (swt) on thier behalf (they are shaheed afterall), others are just happy with asking directly, and of course more than happy for asking the average person to do dua for them. I dont really see the problem eitherway, to each thier own. :)
One cant say Ya Muhammad (SAW). He was our Prophet (SAW) ---Ya may only be used when using Allahs name. Theres a difference.
oh, what does 'ya' mean literally?
It doesnt matter much though, most people use 'beh Muhammadin'.
Re: thoughtful and funny
[quote]
Ya may only be used when using Allahs name.
[/quote]
not necessarily.
ya means O, it prefaces a lot of proper nouns when talking in arabic. ya rafeeq ya jaban (o friend, o madman) for example are perfectly non shirk incurring phrases.
and so it really comes down to intentions.