This man is a sinner, therefore he is a .....

…Jahannumi?
Okay so this is a question I want to ask everybody. How does Islam view naming a muslim and saying that this person is going to hell?
Yeah I mean specifically pointing to someone and saying that person is jahannumi?

I specifaically want to know whether it is just discouraged or is it forbidden?
Will it be considered a sin for a muslim to say such a thing about another? Or just wrong but not a sin?

Thanks.

It is discouraged to say non-Muslims (especially alive) as 'kafir'... and I'm sure that it is "forbidden" to regard a Muslim as "jahannumi" because being human we don't know actually what will happen to him/her after (s)he dies, also we don't know in what condition he dies... bottomline we can't regard anyone as "jannati" or "jahannumi" it is ONLY ALLAH to decide.


We oughta be Changez like, don't we?

Anyone else...??