They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

I’m stuck in a huge dilemma.

Last week, I had a chemistry exam. It was on a Saturday and my best friend/roommate and I ate fries from the school’s cafeteria the day before. We were both vomiting & feeling horrible that whole night. The next day we could barely get up from our beds due to the immense pain and decided to go to the hospital & as a result, miss our exam. We also had last minute studying to do the day before (looking over a few notes and whatnot) and weren’t able to do that because of feeling unwell on Friday. Saturday morning we both went to the hospital and had to stay there for 5-6 hours.

We told the doctor about our missed exam and he wrote us a note which we gave to our professor. Our professor rescheduled the exam to Thursday the next week so everyone who missed the exam were to show up that day. One of my so-called “close” (back stabber) friend missed it too but not because she had a legitimate excuse, but because she wasn’t ready/prepared for it and “didn’t feel like doing it”. This girl had missed a midterm for the same class last semester, and told the professor she was sick, when in reality she was perfectly fine! In fact, the very day of the exam in the evening, there was a party at our mutual friend’s house and she was dancing and prancing the whole time. I wonder what happened to her “illness” then!! I don’t feel it’s fair to others that one student gets so much extra time to study just because they don’t feel like it whole others who are not that well prepared write it anyway. That time she didn’t ask me what was on it because we weren’t that close.

She always does this and asks people what the exam questions were. It’s not fair to me, it’s not fair to anyone else. I swear to God I could have asked someone too, but me and my friend decided that no one knew the test questions on the actual day, so it’s not fair that we ask either. At the end of the day, Allah’s watching our actions.

The next day I met with another friend of mine and she pulled me to a corner and asked me if there was anything wrong or if she’d said anything to me because she felt I was avoiding her. This friend is very close with the friend I mentioned above so I maintain a distance because I know the other one is not good company! I told her no, and told her the truth: I was avoiding the other girl but since she was always with her, I couldn’t meet her. I told her of all the hurtful things she’d done to me and how much it affected and stressed me out. I used to praise her so much to my mom, until I found out her true colours! My friend told me of the same things she goes through. She basically bullies her just because she gives her a ride to school, and it’s not likes she’s doing it for free so I don’t understand the need for this!
The night before, the other “friend” texted me this:

http://i46.tinypic.com/15rod8i.jpg

Does she think I’m a kid? :S the day that the exam was actually supposed to be on (rescheduled one that she was supposed to show up to as well) , she called me and told me she’s not ready. I told her I’m nearly done and if she wants she could come over and we can go over the material together. She said okay, and I told her to hold on while I go to the bathroom. When I came back, she hung up! I texted her and tried calling her several times but she didn’t reply until she needed something from me! :confused: I thought of helping her, little did I know of the sneaky plan in her head!

http://i50.tinypic.com/2ntejrn.jpg

I honestly didn’t know what to do. So I asked my friend and she told me that she’s just testing to see if I’d tell her or not and the night before when they were driving home together, she called my other friend and asked him what was on already! I was furious! I asked her what I should do and she told me to just tell her, I texted her back and told her what to study in general but nothing too big just for the sake of getting her off my back, which was a huge mistake! I should have told her off and told her that’s a way of cheating but she’s such a big fat bully! I’m only 19, she’s 30 with 3 kids! Wallahi she is SO CHALAAK! My friend told me of all the other things she’d done and said behind my back. I was so hurt, I honestly thought of her as an older sister.

So the poor professor rescheduled it for Friday. Guess what she does? She goes to university on that day, even does her lab with us and then leaves. I asked my other friend what happened to her exam, and she told me she was going to tell my professor that she didn’t read the email and to reschedule it… AGAIN!!! This is the 3rd time she’s doing this! She’s basically lying to him and he’s so nice that he keeps trying to reschedule it just so students can write their exam.

We were at a party today and she lied to my friend that she wasn’t going to come. She called me and asked me if I was going, and I said I’ll see, because I have lots of work. Plus my best friend/roommate wasn’t feeling well & she wasn’t going so I didn’t feel like going either. But then my sisters wanted to go, so I was still contemplating. It was around 4 at the time and I told her that the party starts at six na, so I’ll come then if I can. She said “what?! Party starts at six??” What happened was that she told my friend (the one who thought I was avoiding her) that she wasn’t going to come to her party, and so my friend rescheduled it from 1PM to 6PM. She only did it in the morning because her dad and brothers weren’t going to be home then so she thought it would be more convenient, especially for the other “friend” since she has kids. But then since she said she wasn’t coming anymore, she rescheduled it for the evening. The other “friend” had asked this friend to schedule it for another day, and she said she couldn’t because her family had already prepared for Saturday. Just because of this, she made a HUGE issue out of it, and it was my friend’s birthday on top of that! She makes a mountain out of a molehill! She showed up to the party despite telling her that she’s not coming, and said that she’s mad because my friend could reschedule for us and not her! But she was talking about a whole other day while we were just talking about timings on the same day! Ugh :confused:

Anyway, she showed up to the party and asked me again how my exam was to which I told her that it went well Alhamdulillah. Then I asked her how hers went even though I already know she skipped it AGAIN! She said it was “good”. After a few minutes, I brought it up again and she said, “I actually didn’t do it”. I asked her what she’s going to tell the professor now and she said that she’s going to tell him that she didn’t read the email so that’s why she didn’t show up. :confused:

My friend called me today and asked me a question about an assignment. After a while, I asked him if the friend who didn’t do her exam called her. He told me she did, and that he told her what was on the exam since she asked. I was going to spaz out at him because I was so angry! This guy is a close friend of mine and I could have called him and asked for the exam questions but I didn’t! Because I RESPECTED him and my other classmates. It’s not fair to him, it’s not fair to the others, it’s not fair to everyone who did do the exam. This guy was basically helping her cheat. And I’m sorry if I sound selfish but I don’t think it’s okay for one student who cheated to get 90% and another student who studied all week, day and night to get 70%!!! It’s just not fair!! Not to me, not to him, not to my other classmates, not to my professor!

So basically my question is… what do I do now? I really feel the need the tell my professor this because I don’t feel it’s right that someone is cheating like this and not getting caught! Not to mention continuously LYING to him! That’s just not right!

I’m stuck in a position where I want to tell him, and at the same time I don’t.

I asked my mom what I should do and she told me to listen to my heart… but I don’t know what to do! I told my mom that Allah exposes everyone one day, and what they do eventually comes back to them, but I feel I should inform my professor of this at least.

Why I want to tell him:

  • because it’s not fair. Cheating is just not right.
  • he’ll be more cautious in the future.

Why I don’t want to tell him:

  • if he tells her I told him all this, there will be a HUGE fight and family drama because all of our families know each other
  • my professor will get really angry and will feel betrayed
  • my friend who told this girl the questions might get in trouble too for telling, but this guy is honestly so gullible and naive. I don’t want him to get in trouble too :frowning: my professor may get really angry at him and I don’t want him to end up in a mess… He’ll hate me for life
  • my professor may bring up my name and I don’t want him to.. it’ll cause a huge issue even if he mentions that he knows she asked people for the exam questions.
  • he might even kick her out of the class, which again I don’t want because she is a huge bully with mental issues and if she finds out I told, she’ll go to huge lengths to get her revenge! I’m not kidding. Once we went to a mall and there was a women who flipped the bird at us and she drove so fast around the parking lot just to find her and do the same. Her husband got really mad and climbed on top of my “friend’s” car and started banging it! I was so scared & I told her to drive away or else he was gonna smash the window and beat us up but she stood there for a good 20 seconds thinking of ways to get them back :confused:

What should I do? Should I make istikhara? Should I leave it?

What my professor can do is change the exam, but that’ll be such a hassle for him. I don’t know, should I just tell him and let him deal with it? Perhaps I can tell him not to bring me into it? He’s Muslim too (I think, judging by his name) so maybe he’ll understand?

What do you think?

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

You shouln't do anything.

You study for yourself. Everyone does.
What should matter to you are your own results and the effort that you put in your study.
Her cheating or not cheating will not affect your result. It will only negatively effect her in the long term.

Neither is your professor 'poor' and neither are the students who she uses to cheat the exams.
The students give her these answers voluntary. She doesn't threathen them.
And the professor should use his mind.

Where do you study anyways? That it is so easy to reshedule an exam again and again and the student still doesnt show up and gets away with it so easily.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Don't do anything. I had a friend in high school who was out partying the night before our grade 11 physics exam. She missed it making an excuse that she was sick and went out again that same night. She told me how she cheated on her rescheduled exam and I did feel bad because I had studied so hard yet her final grade in that class was higher than mine. I didn't do anything though and everyone graduated but she had to stay back a year because her overall grade in grade 12 wasn't high enough. She's still in school. You should just study hard and think of your own future. Cheaters never get too far in life.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Betrayed professor? Retaking th exam again and again? Where do you study????

I think you're the one making a mountain out of a molehill. Leave her be. Don't give her your answers, and study and focus on your own exams.

Stop wasting time/mental energy on someone else's shortcomings. You'll be better off in the long run.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Well, since you're the one who will have to deal with the consequences of telling the professor, you need to ask yourself is it worth dealing with all the potential drama you listed above. Its great that you want to do the right thing....but make sure you're prepared to deal with the consequences of your action.

Personally, I would just mind my own business. Causing drama in my life because someone else cheated on a school exam is not worth it in my opinion.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

She fakes not feeling well, goes to a doctor, gets a note from the doctor and hands it in to prove she had a legitimate reason. So it's not like she's just saying oh I missed my exam bc I didn't feel like doing it, please reschedule it and he does, she's faking her illness and showing it to profs so it looks legit. I don't know if her email excuse will work.

And even giving in "legitimate" medical notes again and again like this is only working with him because he's really nice. It wouldn't have worked with any other prof. ESPECIALLY if they knew this same student had missed another midterm.

How old are you?

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

why don't you tell her some made up questions, and also add that you dont remember too well as doctor has given you too many pills and one of them causes memory erasure, and who is this on the phone btw.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Still, why is this a huge dilemma to you?

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

tldr

sounds like you're butting your beak into something that should be the least of your concerns when your sole focus should be on an exam that you've been given extra few days to revise for. thank Allah swt for that and just move on with your life, you're 19.. trust me, worrying about dumbass friends who do dumbass stuff is not gonna make your life better nor is it gonna get you to ace an exam. she'll get her comeuppance ¬¬.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

This may work with the nice professor but not in the real world. Let it be, do your part by not telling her. If she really insists, tell her to study and she will be fine.

It is unfair if a student gets better grades than she would if she had not delayed to get more time for no reason and more importantly asked others what was on the exam.

I would drop the prof an anonymous note, not handwritten, and not pointing out names but tell him the issue if students repeatedly delaying exams and finding out about questions on the test from others and that maybe he can mix up the make-up test a bit. Many profs do that anyways or can do it quite easily.

Then it's up to him. You have done your bit.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

You know what they say about snitches.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

its academic dishonesty.
'they' can say whatever about snitches, I call it whistle blowing, sitting back and not reporting dodgy behavior whether at work, school or community is perfectly fine in my book.

now if someone was using me like that, I would handle it very differently, A) by first telling them all incorrect questions on the test, B) then providing full proof to the prof about what this person did, C) and then telling the person about A and B. Then kicking back with a drink and chilling. cuz..like the honey badger.. I dont care :X2:

the best approach though would be to just tell the person directly that you are not going to help them hoodwink the system. They can take it whichever way they want to.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

I read this part over and over. Made more sense the more I read it. Great advice. Plan to use it myself.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Not going to say what you should do. Because others have given great advice. But I will say one thing that will serve you well (and wish someone had told me 35 years ago)

What you learn in school and college is not just about grades. Yes grades matter. But what is more important is you enjoy the process of learning. When you learn because you want to, and not because you have to, you will retain what you learnt not just for the exam, but for years down thee road.

You already have won half the battle - you are honest. Inshallah, success will be yours.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

If the person in question had stolen paper tests from the professor, or if she has hacked his computer to steal confidential information, then it would have been a different story.

But in this case telling on her is mere snitching.

Asking other students what questions they got on the test is not illegal. I wonder in what sort of institute OP studies. But it is the responsibility of the college/university to test everyone at the same time, so that nobody can copy any answers and pass it forwards.
Even if someone gets ill, the test is never resheduled. The person gets a chance to catch it up during resits. And if you mess up again, then bad for you. Try again next year.

So the it's a failure on the part of the professor and the college or whatever it is.

Actually depending on the student code of conduct, or honor code or academic code at the university, a student has a right and responsibility to report suspected plagiarism, dishonesty, cheating to the university.

Just by providing information on what questions were on a test, it is considered that the provider was a participant in violation of the code.

Knowing and not reporting is considered dodgy as well.

There are rules around such practices, so on one hand we are giving a cheater a free pass because the enforcement of measures to thwart such attempts is not hard enough.

On the other hand, we are against enforcement vis what many academic institutions have instituted as a checks and balances system.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Brilliant pros and cons.

Re: They cheated on the exam and it's just not fair... should I tell prof?

Plagiarism is basically impossible to get away with nowadays. Every somewhat respected institute has a plagiarism detector. So that they will find out anyways.

I still want to know in what sort of institue OP studies, because of the easiness of resheduling tests.

As for passing forward questions, as I said earlier, that is not illegal. Unless they made you sign a paper saying 'thou shall not talk about exam questions'.
Exams are held on the same time for every student for this reason exactly, that it makes it impossible for students to help each other with questions.
If you miss it you get a chance at resits, which again are held on the same time for everyone, for the very same reason.

In OP's case, it makes no sense to report the person. And neither do I understand why OP is suffering from this.