there is no place for kashmiri pandits

[Xtron]

Re: there is no place for kashmiri pandits

@The_Player

The Kashmir issue would have been resolved years ago, if Pakistan hadn’t interfered in 1948 and made a mess of the situation. And as if that was not enough Pak followed it up with attempts in 1965 and 1999, as well as the numerous acts through “non-state actors”. No Indian govt can dare to even talk about plebiscite in Kashmir for fear of public backlash now. And realistically speaking India is far too powerful now for any international third party intervention.

Whether you like it or not, its Pak that has messed up the Kashmir issue and rendered it virtually “un-repairable”.

So, what is your proposal? For one side to lay down arms in hopes the other does as well? And which side do you suppose should do so first, considering that one side doesn’t believe the other namely Indians.Who is going to initiate the peace between the sides? At what cost in terms of future violence, knowing full well how Indian dictatorship in the region have historically treated ceasefires with freedom fighters in Kashmir? What makes you think that peace is possible with you one side only? What makes you think that Pakistan alone should stop hostilities? What about the Indian army who swept into the valley to occupy Kashmir which initiated this war? What about fundamental hatred for the Kashmiris who historically do not want to rule by your country?

Why should Pakistan leave Kashmiris after 60+ years of conflict to leave and make it an open target for Indian dictatorship? You keep saying it is Pakistan that messed up, but as Kant said, an “ought” implies a “can”, and neither (Pakistanis and Kashmiris) can comply with your utopian, naive nonsense.
“Collateral damage” is tragic and undesirable, yes, but so is the one sided point of view you’re advocating here about Pakistan being messed in Kashmir. Now if your indian government would have been true angels, there would have been no Indian soldiers there in Kashmir and confidence building measure with Kashmiris would have taken place. Which I believe it is done by winning the hearts and minds of the people. How? By showing people of Kashmir how peace should be done by showing action. By not throwing bullets at Kashmiris when Indian army themesleves live in a “glass house” in the valley.