Good topic, ehsan. Evaluations of top players. Seeing from a few of your posts, you seem to have good taste in cricket,
I would agree on the same TOP TEST & ONE-DAY TEAMS. But I think batsmen/bowlers play and act under pressures of both variations of the game very diffeently, so
I did not rate bevan a polite or non-greedy gentleman. But I think his temperament (cricket-wise) is very well suited for the latter part of a ODI innings.
esp. for rapid accumulation of runs, chasing targets, guiding the tail, and shots thru the gaps, particularly off-side.
You need to specify whether you are rating them based on stats or on talent.
In either case, I wonder why Shane Warne is missing from a couple of bowling lists. Also to be considered, Ijaz Ahmed, regardless of his stats, hes one of the most talented hitters i have ever seen. And what about Shoiab Akhtar? He is after all, the fastest bowler around.
hmmm quiet a waste of time when all of this analysis dont effect on the rest of the world...hmmmmm my quick comment so i dont go empty handed...waseem akram best bowler and saeed anwar best batsman...bring you man...you cant beat em....