The ruling regarding the veil for women in Islam

Assalam Allaikum to all muslims,
This is actually in reply to zaraatif about the veil being a commandment of Quran or not. Here is the ruling that I have discovered along with the website address.

"“O Nabi! Say to your wives, your daughters and to the women of
the Mumineen that they draw over them their jilbaabs (outer
cloaks or burqahs). That (i.e. covering themselves with jilbaabs)
is the least (minimum requirement which they should adopt)
so that they be recognized and not be molested (by shameless
people of loose morals)”. -(Surah Ahzaab. aayat 59)

               "And (O women!) remain within your homes and do not make 

     an exhibition (of yourselves) like the displays (of the immoral women) of former times of
                                ignorance". 

         - (Surah Ahzaab, aayat 33) Rasulullah Sallallahu alaihi wasallam said: 


           "Women have no share in emerging (from their homes) except in
                       cases of necessity". -(Tibrani)

                                   

 The narrations of the Qur'aan Shareef and Hadith on the subjects of Hijaab (Purdah), Satr and Haya

are numerous. These narrations with their attendant masaa-il (rules) will, Insha’ Allah, be discussed in
this booklet. Two Qur’aanic verses and a hadith have been mentioned at the commencement of this
article. The purpose for this being:

 (i) To indicate that the Law of Hijaab is a Command of Allah Ta'ala and not a concept foreign to
 Islam as some people who have strayed from Seeratul Mustaqeem would like Muslims to believe.
 Their obsession with Westernism induces them to argue away the Islamic law of Hijaab as a
 practice unsubstantiated in Islam. 

 (ii) To derive barkat. A discussion commenced with the auspicious words of Allah Ta'ala and
 Rasulullah Sallallahu alaihi wasallam is blessed with the permeation of holiness. 

Rasulullah Sallallahu alaihi wasallam said:

“Hayaa (or shame and modesty) is a branch of Imaan”.

The importance and significance of shame are amply borne out by this statement of Rasulullah

Sallallahu alaihi wasallam. Imaan is fundamental to the existence of Believers. Without Imaan man has
no true existence. Imaan is the basis of success and the pivot of najaat (salvation) in the Aakhirah. The
attributes of Imaan are many and among such attributes Hayaa (Shame) is a very important and
significant quality. The opposite of shame is audacity or shamelessness which according to the hadith of
Rasulullah Sallallahu alaihi wasallam is a branch of kufr. The greater the degree of shame in a Mu’min,
the more beautiful will be his Imaan. Shamelessness is an indicator of kufr of which there are varying
categories and degrees. The greater the degree of kufr, the higher will be the degree of shamelessness
and immodesty.

Divine Wisdom has willed shame as a natural quality of women. Woman’s natural quality of modesty
becomes spiritually adorned and lofty with the accompaniment and development of Imaan. The modesty
of Muslim women - those women who have not fallen prey to the brutal onslaught of Western libertinism -
is, therefore, a quality of unparalleled excellence, nobility and beauty.

Elimination of shame introduces its opposite, viz., immodesty in the wake of which ensues

immorality. Immodesty is an essential requirement of immorality. Total elimination of shame results in
corresponding total immodesty while partial elimination of hayaa (shame) brings about partial
immodesty. It is a moral principle that immodesty in a human being will be in proportion to the degree of
the elimination of shame. It is a natural law that when an attribute in man is destroyed, its counterpart
asserts itself. Thus, when generosity is effaced, niggardliness sets in; when courage is destroyed,
cowardice enters; when truth is destroyed, falsehood asserts itself. In the same way, when Hayaa is
annihilated, immodesty with its accompaniment of vice and immorality overwhelms man.

It is also a natural law that the impact and intensity of an attribute will correspond to the impact and
intensity of its opposite attribute. We, therefore, observe that the degree of immodesty and
shamelessness in a lewd, shameless and immoral woman is unmatched. No one can become more
audacious in vice and immorality than a woman who has utterly annihilated her natural attribute of
Hayaa. The avalanche of immorality and exhibitionism of perversity centering around the female body, up
for public display, bear loud and clear testimony to this natural law. The dismal mutilation of morals of
the West being keenly imitated by present-day Muslims caught up in the full glare of the sexual cult of
libertinism offered by the Western kuffaar is the bitter fruit of the destruction of the Divine measure of
Hijaab which Allah Ta’ala has ordained for the preservation of man’s morality, from the very inception of
mankind. Muslims should halt a while and ponder! To what extent have they wounded their Imaan by this
vile pursuit of liberalism and libertinism ? Let them assess the defect which they have introduced into
their Imaan by the elimination of Shame which Nabi-e-Kareem. Sallallahu alaihi wasallam said is “a
branch of Imaan”.

Allah Ta'ala is the Khaaliq (Creator) of man and woman. He is Aleem (the One of Knowledge) and He

is Khabeer (the One fully aware). He has created in man and woman the capacity of the lowly nafs and
He is thus fully aware of the carnal, bestial and inordinate promptings and demands of the nafs. Among
the measures ordained by Allah Ta’ala to curb the desires of the nafs and to hold it imprisoned within the
confines of purity, morality and spirituality are the rules, regulations, etiquette’s, restrictions, prohibitions
and exhortations which pertain to the Islamic practice of Hijaab (Purdah). Islamic Hijaab or the moral
code of conduct to be observed by man and woman in their mutual conduct is a Divine institution
designed by the All-Pervading and Ever-Wise Intelligence of Allah Ta’ala to maintain the dignity,
spirituality and honour of human beings.

Islam demands of its adherents a moral life of the highest purity. Fundamental to this attainment is

the strict segregation of the sexes or the observance of Hijaab. Mingling of the sexes is permitted only
by two circumstances:

(1) MAHRAMIYYAT and (2) NECESSITY.

 (1) Mahramiyyat in the context of Hijaab is the family relationship (of blood ties) which initially and
 permanently prohibits marriage among people who are mahareem to one another, e.g. between
 brother and sister; between father and daughter; between uncle and niece, etc. 

 (2) Necessity in this context means all cases and circumstances which are considered by the
 Shariah as valid grounds for relaxation of, or concession in, the normal strict observance of
 Hijaab, e.g. an emergency; medical treatment; appearance in a court of law, etc. 

This factor of necessity which is cause for concessions in the Islamic law of Hijaab cannot be
interpreted loosely and subjected to the desires of the nafs. For example, a woman cannot leave the
confines of her home on the pretext that she wishes to engage in trade or in some other mundane or
spiritual activity. Concession to emerge will apply only if circumstances compel such emergence. A
woman may have absolutely no income and no one to provide for her; there may be no mahram male or
any other person from whom she is able to learn the necessary Shar’i masaa-il pertaining to her daily life
or she has to attend to her ailing parents, for example, then such circumstances will he considered as
necessity and grounds for relaxation of Hijaab partially.

Every case and outing which people regard as necessary will not fall under the Shar'i scope of

necessity, and concessions in Hijaab will not be granted by the Shariah. Insha’ Allah, these two
factors, viz., mahramiyyat and necessity, will be discussed in greater detail in this booklet."

The website is http://www.shariah.net/hijaab/contents.htm

Iqadeer,

Thanks for all your posts on this subject!

I am interested in what the Quran says on this issue of hijab because it is the only source that everyone accepts as valid. I, like many others, am sceptical of the opinions of scholars. If you say that a particular issue is decided because a certain scholar spoke on it, I can certainly quote another scholar who disagrees.

Also, I do not accept the words you have put in parentheses between the words you quoted from the Quran. If Allah had wanted us to hear those words he would have put them there himself.

Concerning Hadith, I don't necessarily believe in their validity either. Allah has said that the Quran is complete and that we should follow only it. If he wanted to stop us from something he would have stopped us in the Quran. He also says that we should not listen to those who prohibit us from things that the Quran does not prohibit.

I have researched the particular verse that you quoted from the Quran that talks about women's clothing, and have concluded that this verse say that women should draw their CLOTHING around their breasts. The word that is used is the general word that was used for clothing, I believe. I have looked this verse up in a concordance of the Quran and have read many articles on it. Also, there is no reference to covering the head or the face in the Quran. These are ideas that have been imposed on us by those other than Allah.

The second verse that you quoted (about women not leaving their homes)from the Quran was directed specifically to the wives of the Muhammed, who had to lead restricted lives because of their special position. Other women are not subject to these same restrictions.

Thanks for giving me a chance to state my opinion!

Zara

salam zara and qadeer and otherz !

guys, can i jump into your discussion?.. well I am already in….. kerlo jo kerna hai..main to buk buk ker kay he jaoon gee…. first of all i would like to say that i am not good at english so please bear with me. J…..

qadeer uncle/phupha/chacha/bhayya/ wagaira wagaira.. thanks for sharing the idea but you know i agree with zara…her critique is quite strong… i am also unable to find any clear verse referring to head covering… the only words which quran says is to control your gaze, cover your bosoms and guard your privates and that’s it, this is followed by a long list of relations for whom these rulings are applicable…

taking a birds eye view on great religions concludes that covering head is not specific for females only, also it is not definite to islam too…(eesaee, yahoodi, hindu etc saray puranay loog apna sir dhaamptay thay… topi aur chader ka mazhab say zeyada tehzeeb say taaluk hai, kyun theek kaha na?) …the real gist of covering the head specifically, in my opinion is that to avoid the surge of perversion in males… studies have shown that males are more prone to stare upper one third of female bodies to achieve some sort of pleasure… varying from person to person, some acquire gratification from silky hairs, some from small ears some from long slender necks and so on…

a female body thus is always being a symbol of beauty for males… so by giving a minimal exposure to all those unpleasing eyes seems to be a more logical and applicable speculation for covering head & shoulders…

a similar topic has already been discussed earlier by mahnoor, and overthere someone (i think zalim or xtreme) has given a very nice point that the veal is said to be complete when it gives a cover to the soul along with the physical visual protection… the discussion is linked below..

http://www.pak.org/gupshup/Forum13/HTML/000436.html

ok its tea break now… (actually its a tylenol break)… see you laterz aligaterz… bus aaj kay leya itna kafi hai… meri ungleyoon main dard shroo ho gaya hai… pta nahin aap loog itni lambi lambi posts kaisay likhtay ho…


CHANDA

[This message has been edited by CHANDA (edited July 07, 1999).]

Asalamu Alaikum,

I am in no way saying that the Qur'an is incomplete, but I am saying that we have to look at the life of the Prophet(SAW) to understand the context and application of some of the verses.

Here are the verses:

"O Prophet, tell your wives and daughters and the believing women to draw their outer garments around them (when they go out or are among men). That is better in order that they may be known (to be Muslims) and not annoyed..." (Qur'an 33:59)

-> 1. A woman in hijab is recognized to be Muslim right away to anyone who sees her
-> 2. A woman in hijab is less likely to draw the negative attention of men

"And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty; and that they should not display their beauty and ornaments except what must ordinarily appear thereof; that they should draw their veils over their bosoms and not display their beauty except to their husbands..." (Qur'an 24:30-31)

-> Hair is considered part of a womans beauty and ornament

And we all know the hadith:

"Ayesha (R) reported that Asmaa the daughter of Abu Bakr (R) came to the Messenger of Allah (S) while wearing thin clothing. He approached her and said: 'O Asmaa! When a girl reaches the menstrual age, it is not proper that anything should remain exposed except this and this. He pointed to the face and hands." (Abu Dawood)

-> This makes it clear for us as to what should be covered and doesnt have to be

I choose to accept these verses and hadith as proof as to why hijab is mandatory, what you choose to do is up to you.

W'salam

[This message has been edited by Yacoob (edited July 09, 1999).]