The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

Article on the Pakistani Rock Band from USA

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18986984/site/newsweek/

Slam Dancing for Allah
Muslim punk rock—it’s not as bizarre as it sounds.

By Matthew Philips
Newsweek

June 11, 2007 issue - It’s near midnight in a small Fairfax, Va., bar, and Omar Waqar stands on a makeshift stage, brooding in a black tunic and brown cap. He stops playing his electric guitar long enough to survey the crowd—an odd mix of local punks and collared preps—before screaming into the microphone: “Stop the hate! Stop the hate!” Stopping hate is a fairly easy concept to get behind at a punk-rock show, and the crowd yells and pumps its fists right on cue. But it’s safe to say that Waqar and his band, Diacritical, aren’t shouting about the same kind of hate as the audience. Waqar wants to stop the kind that made people call him “sand flea” as a kid and throw rocks through the windows of the Islamic bookstore he worked at on 9/11. Waqar, 26, the son of a Pakistani immigrant, is a Muslim—a punk-rock Muslim.

Muslim punk rock certainly sounds like an oxymoron, especially since fundamentalist Muslims condemn all music as haram (forbidden). But Diacritical is one of about a dozen Islamic punk-rock bands throughout the country, bands with names like Vote Hezbollah, the Kominas (“*******s” in Punjabi) and Al-Thawra (Arabic for “the revolution”). The bands vary in sound, polish and success: the Kominas’ funk-infused Bollywood songs have been on rotation on the BBC, while sounds of explosions and gunfire punctuate Arabic chanting on the MySpace page of Al-Thawra. But they’re alike enough to tour together this summer, ending Labor Day weekend in Chicago at the usually staid Islamic Society of North America’s annual conference. Muslim punkers call their brand of music taqwacore—a blend of the Arabic word for piety, taqwa, and “hard-core,” the English word for musicians who want to be taken very seriously. “The Prophet Muhammad was all about smashing idols,” says Michael Muhammad Knight, a Muslim convert whose 2003 novel “The Taqwacores” is a manifesto for the Muslim punk movement. “And what’s more punk rock than that?”

Punk has always been home to the marginalized and angry, led by the Sex Pistols and the Clash in Britain and the Ramones across the pond. But Muslim punk rockers are fighting a two-sided establishment: one side West, the other Middle East. To them, the war on terror is unequivocally a war on Islam, but they’re equally infuriated by Islamic fundamentalists and the bloodshed they foment against Westerners as well as other Muslims. “It’s not like I’m choosing sides,” says Kourosh Poursalehi, 18, who wears a denim vest with a print of Ayatollah Khomeini on the back—for the shock value. “To me they’re both wrong. Bush with the war is doing horrible things, but there’s not a person in my family who’s happy with the Islamic revolution in Iran.” These punks are the first generation of American-born Muslims; their parents came to the United States in the 1960s, '70s and '80s. They grew up just like most kids their age—playing videogames and listening to music. But in their midteens and early 20s, they suddenly had to come to terms with their dual identities. “It was 9/11 that first made me conscious of my ethnicity,” says Shajahan Khan, 23, the son of Pakistani immigrants who grew up outside Boston. The day after 9/11, a classmate asked him what his people had done. “I was like, ‘What people? My people from Cambridge or Boston?’” says Khan, guitarist of the Kominas.

Admittedly, these Muslim punks aren’t especially devout, at least in the tradition-al sense. None goes to Friday prayers regularly, but they all say they’re deeply spiritual. To them, Islam begins and ends with one’s personal relationship with God. After a recent show at a Manhattan bar, Waqar felt the urge to pray. “I went into the men’s room, got down on the nasty floor and started praying,” he recalls. Nothing says Muslim punk rock more than searching for Allah on the floor of a nightclub bathroom.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

thank you thank you thank you for opening a thread on them.

i've heard a couple of songs of the kominas on their myspace (really k a m i n a...they just spell it that way) and i have to say it is so refreshing to hear muslim punk rock. such a huge difference from the regular rapping and what not, which does not really appeal to me. and it's cool how they mix in like bollywood stuff with punk rock.

taqwacore really needs to be put out a lot more out there. but i expect a lot of "devout" mullahs would condemn it greatly. but really, i say, what is more punk than Islam :D

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

is it kaminas spelled incorrectly? :D

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

yup :p

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

Kummar bhai,

It's refreshing to see a Hindu guppie (albeit with an americanized spelling) enjoy Muslim music. In a tit-for-tat move, I can't say that I like bollywood but I do appreciate you participating in this thead.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

awww LI I'm so proud to see a fellow urdu speaking Pakistani know his urdu so well. It just makes me a tad bit teary.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

i'm blown away by the linguistic similarities between farsi, urdu and hindi.

khomeini is farsi, komina is urdu. same meaning.
khumar is urdu, kummar is hindi. same meaning.

wow!

moin.ul.atiq

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA


'
only a queer guy like you would care..... insolent pig !

anyways
this band seem more concerned about expressing their asian cultural rather than religious identity
...a desperate plea to be accepted in a community where are they largely treated as 2nd class citizens
otherwise what is muslim about punjabi music and bollywood ? why isnt midwestern alternative rock or indie rock any less muslim by the same logic

another feather in the cap of the "moderate muslims"

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

There was a Guardian article on this Taqwacore stuff a few months back. I'd post a link but I don't think I'm allowed to yet.

This Taqwacore book (or books) sound really f*cked up.

The following quote really stood out to me "Neither he nor his taqwacore comrades confess to embracing the more debauched antics of the novel - which has one character urinating over the Qur'an and then reading from it and a female Muslim veil-wearing punk, performing oral sex, onstage, in front of 200 people."

Why would any Muslim be influenced by such a book? Sounds like trash and provides more proof of lost young souls attaching themselves to anything to feel cool.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

Takes a "komina" to know a "komina (kameena)" I guess...

:D

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

Heard of these guys from the muslimwakeup days.

The site is mostly dead, like the so-called "Progressive Muslim Union".

They took everything but Islam seriously, yet for some reason insisted on maintaining a Muslim identity.

Usually, I'm sympathetic to those who struggle with Islam. This crowed though...they seemed to feign interest with Islam simply to have it serve as a vehicle to attack Islam from the "inside", as it were.

There were a few who were serious though, but they too didn't buy the concept. One made an interesting observation...so long as these "progressive" types were harping on about Islam, and did nothing to prove their devotion, they could never be taken seriously.

Say what you want about the Mullah...but he's the guy who wakes up well before Fajr, opens up the Masjid and leads the prayer. While most of us sleep. No fatwas. No politics. No fire and brimstone beating of a war drum. None of the stuff that so-called mods and progressives rail against.

These hypocrites go on and plead for a more spiritual Islam. And so there you have it. Men and women *forcing *themselves to remember Allah...because they love Him. Nuts to the timings imposed on us by modern industrial society (is that punk?). No fatwas. No politics. No fire and brimstone beating of the war drum. No progressives. Go figure.

No? Not good enough? Who shall lead the way? A bunch of beer guzzlin Kaminas? No thanks.

There is no fine line between devotion and marketing. The novelty of a Muslim punk band quickly wears out when it's demonstrable that they're more punk than Muslim.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

Horrible music

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

picoio they are not really that much punk either.

Re: The Kominas - A Pakistani rock band from USA

I thought I agreed with them when I read the bit about them being both anti-Bush and anti-Mullah (terrorist variety) but after visiting their website and reading that bit about the Koran, that's too much to stomach even for me.

As for their music, well punk is just so gay, only moshers are into it over here, I guess Pakis in America think it's cool or something, not to mention they're pretty crap but the boy at the front with the blue guitar (Basim?) is quite fit for them sort of guys, the monkeys at the back with the kameez and the check-shirt just look like your typical disorientated coconut Pakis.