Re: The issue of Fadak
Well now the topic has evolved from Fadak to panicle of Ummah…
Well Hz. Aisha is the Um-ul Momeenin (according to the Quran) and any kind of accusation and allegation (esp. insult and offense) is directly towards Prophet Muhammad (PBUH&HP), therefore I am not in favor of this. If any brother is doing it, please don’t.
According to my limited knowledge Hz. Aisha has no role in this episode of history, so why is she discussed here? (whether wives of Prophet are part of "Ahl-e-Biyat" or not, I think it is separate issue)
Brother Psycha has right to differ. But since thread was with sole purpose of Fadak from Shiites point of view therefore such sentimental standpoints are merely in the foot notes of this thread. This issue has a very much political as well as ideological relevance especially to Shiites. And we just don’t believe everything went well from the day of demise of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH&HP), a lot happened and especially with Ahl-e-Biyat. And according to our sources (and sunni as well) Prophet left two things behind one is Quran and second is Ahl-e-Biyat and it is our duty to highlight their eve of happiness and grievances and be part of it…. . We count event of Fadak another tragedy….
And as it is said, she was grieved just because of a piece of land, it doesn’t make sense, I totally agree, it really doesn’t make sense to me either. But history tells us she was much grieved, why? To see what is going to happen to her father's scarifies for the establishment of ISLAM. Now these people will decide what is right and what is not, now their word will be as holy as the word of Prophet of Allah (SWT) and yes history tells us she was grieved and told her husband berry me at night, and never let these people participate in my burial…. . She was buried in night with the grief…
Whatever the reasons were Bibi went in the court (so called since we believe it was not a legitimate one) demanded her right along with were Hazrat Ali(AS) and Hasnain Kareemain (AS) and it was denied, she contested the discussion but decision was already made, because if she is given fadak today, she will demand for Khilafat tomorrow… .
Regards.